Follow
Share
Read More
Apparently you haven't read the posts where the duty bound adult child cared for the parent, at her own expense, and was left homeless, penniless and half dead after the parent passed away?

When you decide to face reality that a bag of groceries that used to cost $20 now cost $65, and a gas and electric bill is now $300 a month, perhaps then you'll understand why unpaid caregivers need money to survive.

What the world has come to is that nobody can afford to live anymore. Unless you are super wealthy, which you must be for even posting such a question in the first place.
(4)
Report

I think that Florida won't have any problems with "judgement" since her post to us is quite judgemental.
(4)
Report

Alvadear honestly I don't think I heard that story 😞
(0)
Report

Just to add, my duty is to take care of myself, so that my children can raise there family, enjoy there lives. I will never take that away from my children.
(3)
Report

Yes everyone has a right to there opion, I'm not disagreeing with that. And I'm glad you were able to do what you did. I'm not judging you or your opinion at all.

It's others judging my opinion that is wrong, when they don't know my story or others stories.

And some people are just not made to be caregivers , that the way they where born , that is just the way life is. Society forcing someone to be a caregiver, that is just not a caregiver type of person, is a recipe for disaster, aging abuse, suicide, you name it

As far as Duty, I do nothing out of duty, I do what I do out of love, if my husband said it is my duty, to cook his meals, that will be the last meal I cook, untill he changes his perspective.

And another thing is people are living a lot longer, for a lot longer unhealthy than they ever use to.
(4)
Report

Welcome, Florida!

I think the problem here is the unconditional "should".

Should an adult child give up their livelihood, or their marriage, or raising their minor children in order to provide hand's on care for their parents?

What about mentally ill, abusive or abandoning parents?

If the parents has funds to replace the child's wage-earning ability, where is the problem with paying them for care?

We posters are from all over the world, with differing economic means and personal situations.

I could never have cared for my mom myself. I could not afford to give up paid work; I live in a tiny apartment; my mom and I were like oil and water most of the time. Fortunately, mom had the funds to private pay for various levels of care, including nursing home care for 4 1/2 years after a stroke.

I also did not have the medical training to detect when mom was suffering from UTIs, CHF symptoms or depression. She got far better care in the NH than she would have had at my incompetent hands.
(8)
Report

Yes, you most certainly are crazy.

Who was paying your bills while you were doing all that? Not everyone has an endless amount of free money rolling in like you evidently did. People have to work and be paid to support (and insure) themselves.

Take that silver spoon out of your mouth and observe the real world sometime.
(11)
Report

I helped with both of my parents, gladly and out of love. For my mother, her care needs were overwhelmingly complex and I’d defy anyone to be able to do it all in a home setting. She lived in a nursing home but that didn’t mean our family wasn’t involved in caregiving. Our visits and advocacy for her certainly made a positive difference in her care. With my dad I helped him in his home to the end. I took him to endless doctor appointments, grocery runs, medicine pickups, etc. helped around his house, whatever I could. This had to fit my schedule, not his, as I was also raising four teens and working part time. I wasn’t paid to help him. Caregiving has to work for the caregiver, family or not. A family caregiver giving up needed income, all friends and social life, and deciding there’s honor in becoming some kind of martyr to the cause isn’t healthy for anyone involved. There are endless variables in what our elders may need and ways to accomplish them. What works for someone isn’t always wrong, just different
(6)
Report

We are to HONOR our parents if you are a believer. Not to take care of them as tho they are our children. They are not. Whether by accident or on purpose people choose or choose not to have children. They are OBLIGATED to those children until they reach the age of majority. Then that obligation stops. They are not obligated to pay it backwards or they would NEVER get out from under obligation.
Your obligation is to your children. Their obligation is to THEIR children, NOT TO YOU.

Parents are obligated, after their children are raised, to raise funds to care for themselves as they age. Not to burden the most free time of their own children's lives with their care.

As to Christian duty, it seems each Christian makes up the rules according to his own church's interpretation. As I am a non believer I am obligated not by any idea of a god dispensing rules, so I guess I am out on that one. I believer we have a moral obligation to our children TO BE SURE. And to ourselves to make the best life we can, and to give support we choose to give to those we choose to give it to.

You have made your choices. I honor your right to make your own choices. I am thrilled to hear you were happy in the choices you made and are comforted that you made them. You do not, however, make choices for the rest of the world. You certainly can hold opinions about it, and we appreciate hearing them.

Best out to you.
Don't make me repeat the father eagle carrying his eaglets across the raging waters story. All here are thoroughly bored with it, ha ha.
(6)
Report

Florida, not everyone can afford to forsake their work by caring for a loved one without pay.

Quite frankly, I find your post judgmental and unkind to those in situations that you can not fathom.

Getting paid or not has nothing to do with love or Christian duty.
(13)
Report

Start a Discussion
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter