Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Perhaps think about this from another perspective. At about $20 per hour, you are paying for 300 hours of care per month. I doubt she needs 2 baths a day - most NH do a bath every other day. A whole week without a bath is not quality care at all. If they have no activities at all and she is just laying in her bed or sitting in her room alone, how often do you think they even come by to spend a little time with her. Probably not very often. Out of sight and out of mind. More than likely she sees someone 3 times a day for meals, maybe one or two more brief drop-bys to bring a snack. Overall, do you really think she gets anywhere close to 300 hours of 'assistance' in a month? I doubt she gets 200 hrs of assistance.

Based on her current activities and care she is receiving, other than being bored out of her mind, she is managing with a very solitary life. What if you found some in-home health at about $20 to 25 per hour to provide assistance to her in your home. Clearly she doesn't need 24/7 eyes on her every move - she's not getting that now. Maybe hire two different people - AM person to do bathing 2-3 times a week, get breakfast, meds and pick up around her bedroom. Start with 2-3 hrs for that shift. Afternoon or evening - another 2-3 hrs to prepare a meal, a load of laundry a couple times a week, etc. You may have enough leftovers from your own meals to have a lunch in the frig to heat up for her in the middle day.

I think her money would be better spent to get actual hands on care for her - and perhaps less than she's spending now. In your mind, you might be thinking that $6K a month is getting her 24/7 care and that's why you can't afford it at home. But, that is simply not the truth. She's not getting anywhere to close to that kind of care. That's why it's called 'assisted'. NH is for people who need 24/7, and you'll even find similar issues there. If her care actually reaches a 24/7 need, then a NH might be the better option at that time. Just doesn't appear that assisted living, where she is, is worth what she's spending.

You might also look for another facility. This one is just one of those who is willing to take the money, but lower the level of service by using covid as an excuse. Many facilities did as little as possible before covid was even an issue, but now they seem to blame staffing and lack of care on something that everyone sees on the news every day. Not saying covid is not real - it is - however there is no reason the can't have some sort of activity.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
rovana Aug 2021
Sounds like "assisted living" covers a range from "almost independent living, but with cooking and laundry done for resident" to "just about nursing home", with fairly heavy needs.
(0)
Report
As has been correctly stated in previous posts:
1. AL's, slightly understaffed in the best of conditions, are more understaffed now than ever. People would rather work for $15/hr at fast food chains, with flexible hours and free lunches or better yet at Amazon for $18 to $20/hr than in the senior living for $13/hr (kitchen aides start at a whopping 11.50/ in high priced). You better believe AL's, NHs and some hospitals are understaffed in the lower levels. Staff cannot force anyone to participate in showers or activities. Resident's rights and all that!

2. Depending on the situation in the individual facility, activities may be curtailed and dining rooms closed to protect the health of the residents. We have one 4 star facility in NJ that had opened it's dining rooms and started activities in June but closed them this weekend when 10 residents begin coughing and running temps. Everyone (staff and residents) has to be tested again but they are waiting for results before going back to "normal" dining and activities. Bummer for all concerned.

3. ALs are just that. They provide an "assist" to a resident, not full care; in some instances they are almost more geared for the independent living folks who just want a 5 star meal every evening. Hair cuts and styling are extra even in NH's. Housekeeping is usually 1 or 2x per week. I would look to see what level of care you at which you have your Mom. Some facilities include 1 med in the basic entry fee but many do not. Depending on the number of medications, your Mom may need a higher level of care (definitely has a higher cost associated with it).

All that having said I think you should know that the standard marketing tour of an AL is geared for the person (their family) who is ready and willing to move into an AL (you'd be surprised how many people who look forward to it. They are tired of mowing the lawn, getting service people in to check the water heater, cooking dinner for one or two.) The AL allows them to grocery shop more lightly as there is one full and sometimes outstanding meal (usually dinner or lunch) provided. Activities that they like and are interested in are on site. Meals and activities are provided and announced and it is basically on the residents to participate unless they have one of the advertised level of care (here go the rates on the upward spiral again!) in which case they MAY get more of a push toward participation.

You can call the Ombudsman office and your state DoH and report your issues; they may not find neglect or abuse but they will respond to you with their findings. You may need to search for another AL that more closely meets Mom's needs or she might be at the level of MC now; if you can come to an understanding with the current administration and they have good MC service on site you might move Mom there (with a new agreement in place for those services). In any event I urge you to closely ready the agreement you sign (never mind what you were told, it's the written stuff that holds up in hearings and in court rooms), I have even advised my clients who are considering CCRC to have that agreement read by their attorney. That big entry fee is just like buying a house.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My mother's memory care facility quaranteened as a facility, and continued a full schedule of activities. There were some changes of course: restrictions on visits that change with the pandemic status, a robust screening and vaccination program for residents and staff, and no outside activity presenters. But they did a great job of finding pandemic safe activities. It can be done!!!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Cover99 Aug 2021
Watching TV
(0)
Report
It sounds like you are expecting a higher level of care for your mother than the level you signed up for. You may need to look into raising her level of care.

Ala carte charges for extra services are the norm.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Sarah3 Aug 2021
Rip off racket— they start off with astronomically high cost for “assisted living” but they leave out 90% of what assistance many seniors need and then charge extra for assistance!
(1)
Report
No place gives a bath twice a day. I’m sure it was meant to be twice a week which is what other nursing homes do.
You should be able to bring her food or have it delivered as a treat.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Although we now live in a "COVID WORLD" my experiences memorialized in REMEMBERING WHAT I FORGOT (2017) can help answer your questions in addition to educating you and other family members about the many challenges often experienced in todays assisted living environment.

K. Allen
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I SO understand your post!!! Many times over. This is happening to my brother in a rehab, exactly the same thing. I thought it was just this place, but no they are all getting away with murder and the staff are all young girls with no experience. Cant even drop some food off without them loosing it. It's such a shame. They are not thriving they are just existing there and for a price of $6,000 its one of the biggest rip offs i have seen. You can talk to a higher up and think your request will be resolved but no, they don't do anything and they lie. I have given up, don't know what to do nobody will help.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Bks105 Aug 2021
I totally agree. Mom was supposed to have assistance when moving around including going to the bathroom. We were told to just have her call her pendant. She called, no one would come and she would fall. She broke her hip with one of her falls. The payoff was one night that no one came after she fell and she called 911. The fire department picked her up off the floor and the aide showed up as they were leaving.
We moved her home after a year of this and trying two different assisted living facilities. We had to completely redo her bathroom and we now have caregivers come in. Very expensive but at least she is safe and happier.

We
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I hope that if we all complain and fight for better care it could change within a couple of years. Not completely but mostly. I have talked to the other family members of assisted living patients with their share of grief and frustration and has asked them to complain as often as needed. This is how change can come about. Don't act like a victim be a warrier.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Sarah3 Aug 2021
Actions get results better then complaints- I agree about complaining but if families complain and continue pouring f their money into these institutions change won’t happen. Withdraw your loved ones, find alternate care - when you withdraw them let them know in writing the reason why
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
For ourselves sake, we are going to have to keep ourselves as strong as healthy as long as we can. By the way you can get at home care, daily, even twice daily, with some insurances. Renew time is a month away.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My father is 96, I have him at home, I have 3 caregivers. and spent 800 hundred at week, he is never alone, and he seems content.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Daughterllo2 Aug 2021
How much help does your father need? Do you have agency workers and are they working around the clock? $800 a week seems low
(1)
Report
For my2cents: (or anyone interested in having an iPad auto answer FaceTime)
go to settings app
Select accessibility
Select touch
On the touch screen, scroll to bottom and select call audio routing
On the call audio routing screen, select auto answer calls
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

sandola: Imho, there exists short staffing across the board, e.g. in virtually all care settings.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

The best ace would be to let her live with you or a loved one and have her on Hospice.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
TaylorUK Aug 2021
How does that work when the author reaches 87!
(0)
Report
Have you talked to the facility to see if Memory Care would be more appropriate for your mother? It will cost more but more services and attention will be included.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

It sounds like the workers there are rather inexperienced in taking care of the elderly. I don't think it's covid that's causing the problem. I think it's probably understaffed and not enough experienced workers. You might want to redo your home and have in home care the closer you get to eighty.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

my mother went into nursing home in april, had to be quaranteed for 2 weeks, so i did window visits and phone calls. then into a regular room with another woman. that was okay, but due to the timing, they were not doing any activities at the time due to covid and the short staff, which yes.......alot of places have short staff because no one wants to work when they are getting free money to sit on their butts. however, when the NH opened, i still had to wear a mask, but they finally started their bingo, church services, etc.............but now we are back to me having to wear full gear because someone tested positive......so in gown, gloves, N95, faceshield and sweating I can go see my mom. they cannot go out of the rooms.......they are protecting the residents. And yes it can be boring, but hopefully things will get back to a Little normalcy. I do my mom's laundry because they only have 1 person working in that department, so its easier for me to get it one day and deliver the clean stuff about 4 days later when i visit her again in full gear. do i like it........no........but i do it. I wish you luck and hopefully things will get better soon. hang in there.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

some AL have a sort of walk in jacuzzi, which might sub for a shower. ask.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mom has been in assisted living for 10 years and I have had to be her advocate. That means staying on top of her care because you cannot assume that your loved one is getting the care consistently. So much depends on if the facility has enough aides and if they are trained & supervised properly. The problem is the continuous turnover of aides. They are poorly paid and expected to work double shifts when other aides don’t show up for work. I have seen this too many times.

At my moms last care plan, the nurse stated that she is a 2 person assist and needs to move to a nursing home. Yet I am able to toilet her myself, shower her and get her in and out of a car to go to doctor. I have 3 physical therapists who evaluated her and agree with me that she does not need to go to a nursing home. She is able to wheel herself to & from the dining room, stand with help, and follow directions.
I have appealed her discharge and have a hearing with the State this week. I feel these assisted living facilities are happy to take your $ but not willing to provide the care you pay for.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
alzdone Sep 2021
I 100% agree. This was my situation with my husband. I had a nice that was a CNA and gave me a lot of insight to these facilities.
(0)
Report
Please keep in mind that assisted living is supposed to be about elders who could be living independently, making their own decisions, but need help "assistance" to accomplish their ADL's. This is not the same as memory care or a nursing home.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Mom's AL was a very nice place once you understand what the differences between the different levels of care. She got a room and private bath, house keeping 2X a week, showers 2X a week, they administered meds (yes provided through their contracted pharmacy), 3 meals a day plus snacks, and provided daily activities and trips for shopping and sightseeing. All for $4300 a month in Central Ohio.

She was assessed by the nurse supervisor before being admitted to ensure she was able to live with minimal assistance. Because she was a fall risk one of the aids would sit in her room while she showered but didn’t help. Side note: some facilities like to assist in showering and dressing to watch for signs of injury or skin problems. The staff ratio was 2 daytime aids and 2 nurses for 48 residents, 1 aid at night with a nurse on-call.

Mom was able to dress herself, made her bed everyday, keep her room tidy, and using her walker get around the facility and out to the transport without help. Having them administer her meds was a huge help because she kept forgetting which ones to take when. She wasn’t a fussy eater and enjoyed the soups. The facility provided space for a stylist to work one day a week to cut and style hair for a low fee.

Just remember that AL isn’t a 4-star hotel, they provide supervision not personal care. Even hotels are starting to reduce rates and have a menu of added, for a fee, services so customers aren’t being charged for amenities they don’t use.

Yes, Covid put a halt to all activities but that happened everywhere. Good places were creative in getting around the isolation. Mom's AL had a fantastic, committed activities director. You might want to move her to a different facility.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I hear your cry and everything you say is l00% true - what should be and what actually does take place in assisted living are world's apart. I will be 88 and live in assisted living because I became disabled and can't walk. It was hell for me in the beginning (l3 years now) and I finally got wise. Even though I am in intense pain, I made up my mind I was going to look after myself and I do 99.9%. I do everything a normal person does (it is very hard, time consuming, painful and frustrating - but I force myself and succeed). I still work two jobs (51 years and 15 years as a Power of Attorney); I handle l00% of my own affairs; take care of my room (their idea of cleaning is l5 minutes); do all my laundry; often prepare my own meals so I get decent food, have lots of hobbies - I do everything. I even saved my life on four (4) separate occasions because no matter how I buzzed for help - NO ONE CAME. I saved my life in the worst one where I was 95% dead and unconscious for 24 hours. My dialing 911 and getting emergency heart surgery saved my life. They did NOTHING in any of the four situations even though they were critical. So if you live in a facility, YOU HAVE TO DO IT YOUSELF TO MAKE SURE IT IS DONE CORRECTLY AND IN A REASONABLE TIME FRAME. There is no other way I know of.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I have worked with dementia patients for almost 30 years, some very close to the end of their life where they work totally against anything and everything you try to do for them, including bathing. They either put themselves on the toilet/commode or I do. Then, I have towels, washcloths handy and get busy cleaning them. They will yell.. maybe scream acting like you are killing them.... I also have a large cup handy and fill with water and pour down their front and back while they are on the toilet. May get the floor wet but, easy to clean up and they are cleaner than they were before! Just put towels on the floor around the toilet BEFORE you start bathing them. And.. you don't have to "clean" everything in the same sitting.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mom is in a Rehab place which is brand new . Yesi its expensive over 7 grand a month. Can't afford round the clock care at home though she wishes she could go home now as she sd its boring. Corvid changed everything. No more bingo or get together n art classes or eating in dining room with your friends. All were confined to their rooms. In May this year they opened it up to visitors with masks shields etc. Was good for 2 months n Corvid hit again.. doors closed for a few weeks.. doors opened again but we decided we stay away due to Delta n sure enough i get a call n a case has popped up. The way I see it they are doing the best they can. My mom has her knitting her books her pyzzels but she won't do it nor write letters or call people. Its her n CNN. She sd she misses sitting in dining room n her friends. They always had a hairdresser come in n she has always used that. I think thats a good idea you signed your mom up. At a rehab place they help with bathing though I was under the impression assisted living they don't as they expect people to do it themselves. That's one reason I didn't pick an assistant living. My mom even stopped using her laptop. So hang in there just call her on phone a lot
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Sandola some of these thing can be related to covid. But to me there are excuses that you are being told that is not related to covid. Like being as they call it short staff. That is a standard excuss use a lot. The are only short staff because they don't want to waste their profit on staffing. As far as showering they are a care facility they are to be trained to know who to be able to get the residents (clients $$$$) to bath. That is way we pay them an out rages amount of money. But it is easier to say the resident (client) won't let them bath you loved one. When my husband was in MC they would not assist him with shaving. So I purchase a shaver and clippers to keep with me and when I visited him I took care of his grooming and washing of his feet. There was a time for weeks and weeks he wore the same socks. When I informed the director I was asked how could I tell. It was a never ending battle to have my husband treated with dignity and respect. One time when I visited him they brought him to me from the dinning room with fecal matter on his nails. That night they had sandwiches for supper. Again I spoke with the director and she asked me to text her the pictures so she can train her staff about hand washing. Five and a half months my husband lasted in the facility. Entered in 7/1/20 sent to ER 12/9/20 with pneumonia 12/17/20 sent directly to hospice 12/26/20 @ 1:06am passed way. Hang in there many prayers for all of you.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter