Follow
Share

I was scheduled for surgery today. When they were prepping me, I found out they wouldn't let me go home unless there was somebody there to monitor me for the next 24 hours. My wife is in a senior care facility and at home is just me and my dog. I then asked them if they ever operated on single people? They said it was a rule. I had never heard of this despite previous operations. Has anybody else encountered this? Thanks.


Alan

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Just noted an ad stating rate is $32.00 per hour, personal
but non medical care, with 4 hour minimum.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Yes, if there isn't family or friends visiting, they will not let you go unless you tell them who will take care of you at home. Luckly, I always had my husband but if not they would not let me leave. My dad and my husband were also told this when they were ready to leave.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My brother lives alone in another state and had to argue this very point with his hospital. He had to use an uber to get home after a procedure because there was no one to pick him up. He threw a fit and said I am alone but that doesn't mean you can deny me healthcare. I think they made him sign something releasing them of any responsibility.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
FivePeppers Jun 2022
In Massachusetts, Uber is not acceptable. It is not considered personal or responsible. Part of the state licensing laws for these facilities. Yes, big big problem
(1)
Report
Depending on the type and severity of surgery you are having, many hospitals and insurance companies want after care, either at home or in a rehab nursing home. Insurance wants you out of the hospital, but usually will continue to pay for recovery in rehab situation. Not unusual.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Every and any procedure I have ever had that required any type of sedation - whether twilight (like for a colonoscopy or a major dental) or full sedation (like for a surgery where you have to be out) and being released from the hospital, they have all required that not only someone be there for me during the following 24 hours but that I had to have someone drive me home - not a cab or ride share service but a person who appear in person.

So, having no immediate family, when my s.o. was not able to assist, I would ask either a close friend, a neighbor who I have a friendship with, or even someone from my bookclub who I have known for several years. Perhaps you have someone you know in a social setting who might be willing to accompany you (you could even offer to pay them for their time and 'service'. In turn, I have also been 'that' person who has been the 24-hour person for a friend or neighbor - spending a night with them when they needed help.

As we age, we cannot count on having family always there to help us. That is why it is so important to form and maintain friendships. I am fortunate for I live in an over-55 active community - actively participating in many of the clubs and social functions has been such a huge blessings in making new friends.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Yes, even having something very minor, they require you to be monitored. You can pre-arrange for a caregiver or companion from a professional caregiver agency to assist you upon completion of your surgery. It’s a safe way of ensuring there’s no medical complications.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Clairesmum Jun 2022
Yes, it is. Paid by the patient, not covered by insurance.
(0)
Report
This is a common recommendation after general anesthesia. I don't know if this is what is happening to you or not. I am also scheduled for surgery (tomorrow, as I write this) and I was told this early in the process. I do feel that patients need to dig for information far too much. I have often wondered, myself, what people who are alone do in situations like this. I assume a social worker helps them, but I don't really know. However, I hope you will not proceed until you can rely on a friend, neighbor, or family member to help you for that first 24 hours. If you have no one to fill this role, tell your doctor immediately.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I was scheduled for a bilateral mastectomy (both breasts removed)for cancer. After seeing the doctor, the office manager informed me it was to be a "day surgery". Enter hospital in the AM, home in the PM.

I thought I had heard wrong. She assured me I had not. That was all insurance would pay for, she said.
I am a registered nurse, but I live alone. I know how to handle drains and dressings, but I was darn sure not going to accept just a Tylenol hyped up with codeine to manage the pain. For once I was thankful I had NO insurance!

I spun around and went back to the Dr. "No", he said, "you stay in the hospital as long as you feel the need!". I stayed only one night and slept fairly well with a pain shot. Then home.
Two to three times a day I emptied the two drains from my chest. I changed a saturated dressing and slept fitfully. I did the exercises they gave me, healed well and started chemo. But I was mad.

Happy to say, several years later I am still cancer-free, and am on Medicare now. but I'm still puzzled by my "day-surgery". Thank goodness I had friends who brought me food and took me to chemo as I was not allowed to drive.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

That is the discharge planners job, if you have no other options , to ensure a safe discharge home. They need to find you a ride and a caregiver that can ensure you are safe at home and arrange home health to stay with you ...by either contacting your insurance company or setting up a private pay service. Medicare will not pay for home care unless you stay a full 72 inpatient hours in the hospital. If they try to tell you that is your problem, inform them that it is an unsafe discharge if
they do not do their job! "Unsafe discharge " is the magic term you need to use. Your local County Aging office may also offer some assistance , and caregivers on their registry are vetted. Very unprofessional that the hospital did not discuss this with you ahead of time. I would shop around for next time ....
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

adler169: They typically do not send a patient to their home when no other resident will BE at the home, similarly to the driver of the motor vehicle necessary.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I am scheduled for my first colonoscopy next month and am both terrified and dreading it. Invasive procedures are one of my biggest PTSD triggers.
DH will bring me and take me home, but I know there is no way he will stay home with me and not go play golf or go to the gym. LOL
After his procedures, he'd be starving and we'd always go right out to eat. I have a feeling that I'll be too mentally exhausted and feel gross and just want to get straight home to bed.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
MargaretMcKen Jun 2022
No need to be terrified, you will get a mini anesthetic and you won't feel a thing. The prep is the problem, and it's not frightening, just a trial. Don't dread it now, it doesn't help at all. Just put it out of your mind until you have to do it. Yours, Margaret
(7)
Report
See 3 more replies
Obviously you were more than likely having an out-patient surgery meaning going home same day as your procedure. This means you will still be metabolizing the general anesthesia you received when you leave to go home. It can take up to 24 hrs to start feeling like you did before the anesthesia, during this time you could make poor choices leading to a fall, a burn when cooking even taking your medication incorrectly so finding someone to monitor you post-op is a safe plan of care.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

One alternative, hire a "Visiting Angel."
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Yes, some surgeries require someone else to be in the home for safety reasons such as use of crutches, pain medication control, preventing falls, making sure to report any complications that may occur, etc. I f no one is available you may be sent to rehab for a short period of time. The surgeon should have checked out your resources of home care while talking with you about surgery. They will contact a case manager to make plans while you are in the hospital.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Another thought about ppst-surgical supervision: double -check with the doctor him or herself. The office staff and the paperwork and the IV technician at the surgery will usually always say you need to be supervised/monitored after surgery, but the doctor has a more accurate assessment of you as an individual, and may have a different opinion. I have routinely had doctors assure me there was no need for overnight supervision. It may depend on the extent of the surgery, but do check with the doctor.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Yes. The health dept or home health worker from hospital should be able to help you. I had rn for 6 weeks to monitor my incision
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Yes. The last time I had surgery they wanted that. I’m a widow so that was a little difficult. My son only lives 3 blocks from me so after a few hours we determined he didn’t need to stay.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

All my family lives out-of-state, leaving me isolated. I,m 66, and my youngest sibling is 3 years older with several health conditions. In these COVID-19 times, I'm wondering if anyone will fly in to see me, let alone stay with me. I will have to count on a few close neighbors the day I will need cataract surgery or other procedures. My disability and anxiety makes me feel worse, but I do the best I can.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Yes.

Arrange for a friend to stay if possible.

This has become more common as hospital stays have become shorter. This requirement is a combination of liability the medical practice refuses to take and a hospital stay the insurance companies refuse to cover in light of a surgery that poses risks and challenges of caring for oneself post-op.

You may be “just fine,” but why take a chance? A fall could be devastating and impact your independence.

You can always hire someone who can clean too. Then, as you recover, you will enjoy your home more.

If you are overwhelmed about the entire situation, ask your doctor if you can be admitted/inpatient for the 24 hours following the procedure.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
FivePeppers Aug 2022
Amazed at your assumptions about a friend stay over.
Not all of us live in the rural or low cost $$$ states. Cannot afford room for guest where I reside, metro
Boston !!!
(0)
Report
Absolutely there is often a requirement that you have post surgery supervision, depending upon the surgery, anesthesia etc. This should have been discussed when the surgery was arranged so you could make arrangements for that supervision. If you have no one who can stay with you or you with them, you might have to hire a Home Health aide to stay with at least overnight. Home Care Agencies offer this service. Sometimes the hospital can arrange a Respite stay, for which you have to pay out of pocket. Nursing Homes and Rehab facilities may also offer Respite Stays (again self-pay), but there is often a 3 to 5 day minimum which is more than you need.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Usually, a person who has an operation needs somebody to monitor them for sedation, pain, and signs of fever or problems. The person operated on is still clearing anesthesia from his or her system for 24 hours - sometimes longer.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Might be because of the medicine they use to put you out or in what they call a twilight sleep. I had something one time and they told me/had me sign a form that said not to make any legal decisions (or similar) after the procedure. I thought, at the time, why are you telling me this info if you already anticipate the possibility of my mental status being a little off afterwards. I mean, I could leave there and not even remember they told me that. Which is exactly what happened. They didn't tell my designated driver and I instructed him to take me to a couple of stores after we left. Apparently, I seemed quite okay. The next day, I found a receipt for a ring I bought and left at store to be sized. I didn't even remember going to that store. We also stopped at a couple more places and then to a restaurant for lunch. Crazy day!!

Now the joke is if I need an outpatient surgery, who will take me so we can shop afterwards! --- Have someone take you and instruct them ahead of time that even if you ask, don't go shopping.

As a note, it might also be a precautionary to watch for bleeding or weakness. Cataract surgery means no bending and eye meds afterwards. If you were alone and dropped something, you might need a little help. Even single people would have to find a buddy.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

They didn't offer to keep you in the hospital?

When I had an endoscopy procedure, I stayed an extra day in the hospital.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
BarbBrooklyn Jun 2022
At least where I live, Cover, most folks DON'T have endoscopies or colonoscopies in hospitals; they have them in free-standing surgical facilities. There is no where to stay overnight.
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
I’ve had this ‘requirement’ put on me with both colonoscopies and my retina re-attachment. I just lie, and go to bed at home. I've always had my daughter to pick me up and drop me off at home. It looks good!
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
FivePeppers Jun 2022
Thanks for the post. State law requires certain factors for discharge. like Massachusetts.....esp. for surgi-centers.
So many solo folks, it is impossible these days. Some town senior centers sponsor care "friends". Pay is going rate maybe $20 to $30 hour Do not know.

I live in a studio. Hard to describe how small !!!
Shower only, galley kitchen. No way to have 24 hr company!!!
(9)
Report
See 1 more reply
Although I understand the need for companionship after surgery, the hospitals are also covered by the pre-surgical consent.  If you haven't read one thoroughly, do so.   Don't forget to spend some time reading the indemnification sections.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Yes, I'm a senior and have gone through this twice, both with disastrous consequences. The first time was in Boston, and the hospital insisted on this process for a colonoscopy. The young woman an agency sent was no doubt on drugs and then robbed me of my then top-of-the-line cell phone, which had a ton of information on it I absolutely needed for a very demanding job I had then. Filed police report, but they did nothing. There was nothing I could do but buy a new phone. When the agency tried to charge me $150 or so for her "services," I hit the roof and refused to pay. The 2nd time was more recently when I had surgery where I live in another part of the country. The cheapest I could find for someone to stay with me 24 hours was $500 cash up front. So, I hired a "friend" -- ha,ha -- of someone I hired where I live to drive me around places; the driving me "around" places individual also proved disastrous (but that's a different story). Anyway, with the lady who was his friend I hired to stay with me paying her cash, I caught her in the act of stealing from me as she was leaving. Just a couple of months ago, when I filed my taxes, the IRS informed my accountant that they were already filed, meaning I am now the victim of identity theft (and still not finished with all the paperwork, which could very well have "hidden surprises" awaiting me.) I am virtually certain the identity theft occurred either:1) by the woman who stayed with me overnight as I slept/came off of the anesthesia, and who could easily have found my social and DOB in my papers; or 2) another healthcare worker who did steal a debit card (fortunately cancelled in time before she used it) and may well have also found access to my ID items when I was in the shower.

It's a cruel, cruel world.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report
mstrbill Jun 2022
My goodness, I'm so sorry this happened to you.
(5)
Report
See 3 more replies
This should have been discussed with you long before the day of surgery.
This should have been discussed with you when they asked who will be taking you home after surgery.
This is standard practice.
Now I will admit I have had surgery and while I did get a ride to and from I did not tell them that there would be no one with me for the next 24 hours.
They are not going to follow you home and make sure that there is someone there.
You are not hooked up to a lie detector when they ask you if someone will be with you.
But for legal reasons they have to ask. Up to you if you tell the truth or not.
(I will say for one surgery, Macular Hole repair, I did have my sister stay with me for a week as I was unable to stand upright, I had to be face down for minimum 7 days)
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
FivePeppers Jun 2022
Read that "face down "prone requirement is no longer required. Signed, Retina issues.
(2)
Report
I just had a colonoscopy with the same requirements.

You can't drive if you've been under anesthesia, and you also can do some dumb things while feeling normal but in reality you're still a bit loopy.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
JoAnn29 Jun 2022
Me, I have to go home to sleep it off. My husband, he wants breakfast at the Diner.
(2)
Report
Yes, this is normal. I am amazed they didn't tell you until the day of surgery. Is there a friend you can call on? A neighbor who will take you home and agree to be "on call for 24 hours?" If not they may insist you stay 24 hours.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Christine44 Jun 2022
In Boston, I knew a guy in my apartment who kept putting off some procedure like a colonoscopy or something because this was his situation: all his family was in another country. He had friends but they were all where he worked and they were all "contract" employees. He said if he asked them to do this for him -- take him home and stay with him for 24 hours -- he was in fact asking them to lose a day's salary, and he didn't feel comfortable doing that. (I guess he could have paid them for their lost day's wages).
(6)
Report
We have a school of nursing in our universities and can usually engage a student to pick you up, stay at the outpatient surgery during your procedure, drive you home and stay with you in your home overnight for a reasonable fee. We see it mostly with eye surgeries and other tests or minor surgeries.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
Christine44 Jun 2022
I'll keep that in mind. Thanks!
(3)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter