Follow
Share

MIL packs al her clothes, pictures, toiletries at least 3x’s a week. She says she’s ready to go home now. I put a sign in her room telling her “you live here, don’t pack your clothes”. I explain to her she has lived here over a year, and this is her room. I have taken every bag, tote bag, Plastic bags, boxes out of her room so that she will have nothing to pack her stuff into. Instead she now just takes everything out of her closet and out of her bureau and puts them on the mini couch that is in her room. It would not be too bad if it was only her clothes she packed because, she can just use the mini couch as her bureau. But unfortunately she packed everything that is in her room, including all the toiletries from the bathroom, paperwork, hundreds of pictures, newspaper articles that were saved, you name it. I am just so tired of unpacking and re-organizing her room. Any suggestions?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Reduce the number of items she has to pack. Give her back appropriate containers for the photos and paper items and toiletries. That will make it easier for you to find what’s needed on a daily basis. If packing keeps her occupied, let her be happy packing. Allow her space to belong to her.
She will not understand what you are telling her about where she lives but she will stop this activity eventually and start another.
Help her pack if you have time and then you will know where everything is when needed. If you have the funds, find her cute bags. Meet her where she is.

Here is a thread from an Alzheimer site that discusses this issue.

https://www.helpforalzheimersfamilies.com/community-voices/your-questions-answered/why-mother-constantly-packs/
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Thank you for the link!, Linda
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
If you continue doing the same actions (unpacking), why are you expecting different results?
Maybe it's time to STOP.
Don't unpack anything. Leave everything packed, slowly each item will be placed back into accessible places.
She is stuck on remembering her previous home, is there a way to help create positive experiences in her current location?
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
her packing things up creates a walking hazard for her. But I never thought if just leaving it there for her to unpack I’ll try that, just will have to make a walkway for her. Thanks, linda
(3)
Report
Not sure how otherwise active she is, but maybe another way to look at it is that's keeping her moving and giving her some exercise.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
I actually thought that... at least she’s able to concentrate the task of packing & getting exercise LOL
(6)
Report
Start removing her things so there is less to re-organize. Dementia loves routine and your MIL has found hers.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I am the caregiver...a daughter who moved in with parents to provide care. When I first read the title, I thought it was about the caregiver packing to leave!! LOL. Mentally, I have done that often!! This weekend I will be attending a retreat for Caregivers.. I have begun to take small steps to deal with how caregiving has impacted me. But honestly...packing up and returning to my life I had previously is something I contemplate often! 😊
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
GardenArtist Sep 2020
See my answer to your comments in the main section; I posted there as it's easier to find!
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I agree with others who recommend adapting to, and trying to find a valid use, for the packing.   MIL is doing this for a reason, albeit it not necessarily one that's cognizantly identifiable.

So learn to work with her, find reason to support and validate her concerns instead of challenging them (although that I think is a typical response).  

Is she mobile enough to go for a car ride?    How cognizant is she?   My thoughts are to mollify her by taking a few bags, going for a car ride (different place every time), which if you're in a state that's already segueing into autumn could be a respite from staying inside.   Perhaps stop at a reasonably priced restaurant (for us it was the Dairy Queen!) to get something to take home. 

When you return, you could either leave the bags in the car or bring them inside to the "new" residence.   Create a welcoming environment, play her favorite music, sit and relax, and she may not realize she's back home.   (That really depends on her level of cognizance.)

If there's anyone else at home who could move a few things around to make the environment appear differently, that might help her interpret that she's in a new home.

Alternately, instead of unpacking, set up a system for her to save her treasures and pack them in an organized storage.    Limit the toiletries, etc.   Let her keep her pictures; they probably mean a lot to her.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
I’ve just been leaving the bag at the door. Eventually she’ll need something that’s in there And I will remind her that it’s in the bag, then she will go through it
(0)
Report
Omobowale, I rather doubt that this is available now b/c of the pandemic, but the Alzheimer's Assn. in conjunction with a local university created a Creating Confident Caregivers program.  Led by a social worker, it offers valuable insights into identifying, interpreting, responding to, and interacting with older folks.  

I see it in fact is still being offered, at least in some area:

https://www.tehachapinews.com/lifestyle/confident-caregiver-series-to-include-living-with-alzheimers-for-middle-stage-caregivers/article_c3bdd6cc-3d61-11ea-a9a1-034c4ebad073.html

This is the one I attended several years ago:
https://www.michigan.gov/osa/1,4635,7-234-64083_87430---,00.html

In addition to studying (no tests though!), interacting with other caregivers, there are problem solving activities which really challenge your mind for solutions.   But finding those solutions allows caregivers to apply them to everyday situations.

I would take it again if I were still in a caregiving situation.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Omobowale Sep 2020
Thank you! I hope this Caregivers’ Retreat offers some encouragement...and good have finally found a counselor. I believe many of my issues are more related to “moving home” more so than the caregiving. I cared for my husband post kidney transplant and after two below the knee amputations (2 different years) Not to mention the months prior doing wound care trying to save the legs. All while working full time.

But this is so much different. I’ve actually given up much more to do this caregiving ...and I moved into the home I grew up in...and they are my parents. So I’m sure the counselor and I will have much to discuss!

I will surely look up your suggestion. I appreciate you taking the time to respond with some good actionable steps!!
(2)
Report
I agree with others who have already suggested that you stop unpacking what she has packed onto the couch. Let go and let that part of things be.

However, I would suggest doing something else with the photos, newspaper articles, papers. Is it possible to put the photos into a photo album? Or digitize the photos and buy one of those photo frames that display digital photos? I would also put the newspaper clippings into a photo album or scrapbook. Or maybe just take home whatever doesn’t really have to be at her place.

Also, in my humble opinion, please take down the sign as it doesn’t seem to be doing any good anyway and may only be upsetting.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Maybe tell her she has to put all the stuff away since she is moving back in now.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Deep inside, she doesn’t feel that she belongs and she is trying to fix the problem herself. Despite your generous hospitality, she may feel inside like a burden or unwelcome. She may feel useless, like the fabled “Bremen Town Musicians” (children’s story about elderly animals who ran away and saved the day for an innkeeper — in so doing regained their reputation and worth). Her brain just isn’t working correctly. Even though you are frustrated and want to correct this misbehavior, anything perceived as criticism may feel condescending, scolding and more confusing - it may cause her to “shut down” even more.

Be as positive as you can. Play along with the plan. “Oh, you’re moving, well that will be exciting!” I like what you’ve done with the place. Or you must be tired after all that packing, would you like to —(insert some activity that makes her calm or happy)— (bake cookies, relax for a while, take a walk, enjoy television or music, a hot bath, help me cook dinner, have some tea —before you go?)

Since she may feel trapped, give her choices- let her plan what you will have for dinner, or manage the TV remote, or even pick an activity for the whole group if she is able.

If she likes the activities related to moving, maybe folding laundry will be enjoyable. Maybe you could say, could you help me pack these things into the laundry basket? Or if you are donating some items, have her fold them for you first. Remind her that her contribution was needed and appreciated.

Take her shopping at a discount store like TJ Maxx and let her pick out a new comforter. decorative pillows or wall art, curtains, or some kind of small furniture to accessorize her new place (her same room). It may feel less strange and more like home if she participates in the transformation.

Change and loss is hard. She may sense her thoughts are becoming increasingly unclear. She has lost control, independence and freedom - principles that people go to war for.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
ArtistDaughter Sep 2020
I like the giving her choices part of your answer. My mom hates being told what to do, but if she has a few choices, even if all end up in doing the very same activity, she feels a little in control.
(5)
Report
OMG this is so annoying my mother did the same, when she could get around telling me I hate it here, I want to go home but her home is with her Mom & Dad sister & brother in the 1930’s. Sad thing is my grandmother died in her arms while she was giving her a bath. But now she can’t walk so she doesn’t pack anymore but still tells me I want to go home.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Even tho she's been there a year, sounds to me she's ready to go home.

Is there a possibility that she could Move In to a room at your house, where she would feel Safer and Loved?

Regarding her packing all her stuff, Next time this happens, Don't unpack anything and leave everything on the couch, where she put it and see whst happens.

If nothing else it gives her something to do and she's getting exercise doing it snd not hurting anyone.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
disgustedtoo Sep 2020
According to OP's profile, the MIL LIVES in their house already:

"She's come to live with me and my husband (her son) since Jan 2019."

Methinks you are assuming OP is another one of us inhuman types who resort to a facility.

This isn't about feeling safe or loved, it is where, or rather WHEN they are living, in their mind. 9 months after moving to MC, from a condo where she lived alone, she forgot about the condo and started asking about HER mother AND the house we lived in over 25 years ago. The first 9 months she pestered my YB about going back to the condo. Nothing about feeling unloved or unsafe, just wanted back to what was familiar in her mind at that time. Since she's already drifted back in time (~40 years, based on certain things she says, I can peg it), she will drift further back as more and more memories are lost. What "home" comes next, who knows. We lived in an apt for a year before that house, then about 7-8 years in upstate NY, then MA before that, including her parents' home. THIS is normal for someone with dementia.

(BTW, my mother, shortly after moving to MC, packed up some items too - these were placed in a cubby in her room and haven't moved since. Also, living with either of my brothers, esp the older one, would be a disaster waiting to happen, or potentially abuse/neglect and I can't physically support her weight, my bathrooms are too small to set up handicap and the only way in/out is full stairs, which she can't do, so I did the best I could in finding her a VERY nice place, near enough to me that I would visit often until the lock down, which continues.)
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Tell her the movers are on strike or their truck broke down and she won't be able to move today. If she is well enough to pack, then she is well enough to help you unpack. Find a way to make a game out of the unpacking.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
disgustedtoo Sep 2020
Can't hurt to try, but this would have to be repeated at least daily, if not more often. She won't likely retain what's been said, any more than understanding the sign that says she lives here, this is her home!

Although she may be "well enough" to unpack, her mind is set on returning to some previous home, so she most likely won't be agreeable to unpacking. Again, it can't hurt to try, but doing this daily or multiple times a day will be no better than OP doing it herself.
(0)
Report
Might want to try putting her stuff away with much less at her disposal. Give her mini toiletries - and keep refilling them from a larger container. Keep less clothes in her closet. Screw the artwork into the wall so they don't come down. When she has packed, say OK and take her for a road trip - without the stuff of course. Maybe go thrift shopping, out for a treat, and let her put everything back when she gets home. Let her keep nice shopping bags from department stores to "pack" and "unpack" her things. It won't stop the packing habit but it may put a happier spin on it.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
disgustedtoo Sep 2020
My suggestion is also going to be keeping less at her disposal to pack. But, I would hesitate screwing anything to the wall. Although she has dementia, strength may still be a factor and she might damage the walls, the artwork or hurt herself trying to take them down!
(0)
Report
Hi, it is impossible to understand where they are in their minds. They really want to go home , to their childhood home.
our mom does this all the time whenever she is alone. The only days she doesn't do it is when we have someone with her all the time, every second reminding her and even that doesn't work. She will laugh and say this is not my home.
we make up so many stories now - things that calm her down like ie. daddy left this house to you so we are here to help you take care of it. No note will work because they just don't get it anymore.
what i found that helped soooo much now is to get her attention away from thoughts. i bought an ipad pro - the big one and put on her favorite musical concerts - primarily andre rei and she sits there in heaven for hours and doesn't think about going home and we talk about stories of her life. I also bought google mini to play music quietly as it distracts her from thinking to go home - she sings along instead of thinking how am i going to escape. I do know that they can't be left alone with their thoughts as they are not current. It is a long road and an impossible climb but keep trying things and hopefully it gets easier. we did ask the doctor to prescribe a mild sedative - mild enough that she can function and so when she gets anxiety to go home - i give it to her teva-lorazem .5mg good luck
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
I will try asking Alexa, to play only 50’s music. She likes that in the car. Thanks for the tip
(0)
Report
My mother in law use to do the same thing. Only she would put everything into large garbage bags and then call us for bogus reasons so we would make an extra visit. I didn't mind doing the visit but I put my foot down about the clothes. I let the staff handle putting everything away. She was in assisted living. Just told her she wasn't ready to come home yet or ask her why she wanted to leave her "apartment".
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Guys, a funny story a friend told me that his mom wanted to go home and the home still existed with family... overseas. He took her there to see what would happen. She loved it and he left her there with the family. I wish i could do that it would be the perfect scenario.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Cye123,
does your overseas’ family have an extra room? LOL
(0)
Report
We experienced this with my great aunt. Just a forewarning, don't be surprised when she uses her pillow case as a bag...that's what my great aunt did. They are very resourceful.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Brielle, now, that’s funny!!! I just got a mental image of Sally with a pillowcase slung over her shoulder, heading out the door.
(0)
Report
My Alzheimer husband did that the last two years he lived. (He just passed in July). My living room couch constantly had luggage on it. He would switch them out from time to time. He was ready to go "somewhere", but he didn't know where. A few times he had all MY ski clothes and paraphernalia packed in one of the pieces of luggage. Nothing else but that. Another time it was just shoes. My daughter would show up and say, "Where ya goin', Mom?" I'd say, "Unfortunately, nowhere". She'd say, "Where's Dad going?" I'd say, "He doesn't know". :-)

Yes, it is the most frustrating thing and a lot of work for you. But I'm sorry to tell you............things will get a whole lot worse than that. Bless you!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Sister46, first let me say my condolences to you and your daughter. Thank goodness Sally doesn’t try to pack any other room but hers so the rest of my home isn’t in transition. Packing the shoes though, now that’s hysterical. I’m sure at the time you probably didn’t think so as you had to put them all back, but I hope you get a giggle out of it now. I’m aware things will only go downhill from here but I have this forum and it’s helped tremendously..... Linda
(0)
Report
My goodness you have your hands full. Take most of the items away and leave just a few. She is probably packing to go back to her childhood home, or the home she was at previously. Do you have any idea why she wants to go? My mother says something similar and most of the time it is when she is anxious or stressed over something. It may be because we want to give her a bath, do some exercises, or if I refuse to count her money over again after counting it about 4 times. She sometimes get red in her face and has a temper tantrum, which she never did before her decline the last few years. I am firm with her in a gentle way and change the subject or distract her. That works for us. I am tired too, believe me I am lucky I get out of bed in the morning and do not fall flat on my face. We need to take good care of ourselves as best we can under the circumstances, otherwise we will be in the grave sooner than later. Good luck and wish MIL and you the best. I commend you for being so caring to your MIL, you must be close, nice to see.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Early bird, She’s not angry when she packs to leave 95% of the time. She says: ok I’ve taken up enough of your time. I’m ready to go home. In the beginning I’d tell her: you live here now and that was enough. Then it wasn’t enough, she wouldn’t believe me and get angry. I did the ‘explaining’ over & over. This forum though, has given me the tips & tricks I need to understand the what and the why about her behavior. Now, I’ve downsized and leave the bags packed. She’ll either live out of a suitcase or put them away herself ( or the aide will do it the 1x/ week she comes in.
(0)
Report
Oh boy. I feel for you. I read a lot of nice suggestions, not sure if anything will work. Does she get out of the facility for short trips?

Here's a thought, that may or may not work. A neighbor had taken her Mom to the doctors. When she returned to her home, her Mom would NOT get out of the car. The neighbor was so frustrated that she was yelling, which caught my attention. I tried, but she refused.

I suggested to my very annoyed neighbor to take her for a short ride to go home. I explained to the Mom that her daughter was taking her home. And I would be there to help her get out. It worked! She had no idea who I was, but a very nice lady. I helped her get out of the car and her daughter and I helped her into her home.

You might try having her son take her "home". In the meantime, you can put most things back, but maybe save a few personal things for her to help you put them back, pictures, personal items.

Good luck. I hope this works.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
disgustedtoo Sep 2020
She isn't in a facility. From OP's profile:
"She's come to live with me and my husband (her son) since Jan 2019."
(1)
Report
Unfortunately my mother does this too. Even worse she takes her sheets off her beds so I have to remake her bed. I feel fo you. It’s very difficult and frustrating! My mom doesn’t read the sign anymore and when I ask her to read it in front on me and tell me what it says, she still can’t comprehend it. Her room looks like a tidal wave hit it. Not the cute space I had created for her, pictures off the walls, all her trinkets I had to lock away, even her mini blinds are all screwed up....again. Know your not alone, I haven’t found a remedy...good luck to you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Have you tried having her write a letter to herself when she is having a moment of clarity? I often wonder if this strategy would help...
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
WOW! Excellent idea
(1)
Report
Unfortunately this is a very common occurrence among those with dementia. Often it's a phase they go through, so one can just try to cope until the next "fixation" takes it's place.

We moved our mother to MC. She packed up items, mainly small items like pictures, knickknacks, wrapped in newspaper (she gets the Sunday paper!) They were in a bag, so I moved them to a little cubby in her room and there they sit to this day (she doesn't seem to go there.) I think she may have packed up clothes initially, but that stopped long ago. Staff would put the items back. She's just past 3.5 years there now.

The first 9 months she pestered my YB to take her back to her condo, where she'd been living alone prior to MC. About that 9 month mark, out of the blue she asked me to drop her off at her mother's and when I deflected that with "too late in the day" and "maybe tomorrow", she asked if I had a key to her previous home, sold 25 years prior! Her mother has been gone 40+ years. Last year she asked about one sister and when I said I hadn't seen or talked with her recently (mom is the only one left now on both sides), she said she's probably tied up with "that baby." I knew she was referring to my cousin's second child. Both were born with a form of MD, the second one totally disabled and mom's sister helped my cousin. That "baby" would be about 40 or so years old now (passed away after surgery error.) So, clearly mom is living her life from 40+ years ago. That will eventually slip back further as time and dementia progresses (she is 97 now, just recently had a mini-stroke, so she may not ever get back to a previous address.)

Although often it works to set up a room like one they had before, it all depends on what's in their mind. Even if it looks like home, it isn't and they know it. Reminders don't really help, and no arguing, explaining or correcting is going to change that. It will only frustrate you and perhaps anger her.

The best suggestions so far were to limit what she has access to. If possible, store only a few days worth of clothing, replacing them with others when the ones she has need to be washed. Limit toiletries and other items in the room. Keep just enough to get through several days. You might also take the suggestions about giving her bags or small luggage so at least the items packed up are "contained."

The artwork should probably just remain off the wall. Someone suggested screwing them to the wall, but she could damage the items, the wall or hurt herself trying to take them down. Since she is hell-bent on taking them down, they aren't doing much to help her "adjustment", esp since it's been a year already!

The less she has access to, the less she can pack and the less you have to "unpack." As staff has told other visitors at mom's facility, you have to live in their "moment." This is their reality and you can't change it, you just have to adjust yourself to it. For instance, if she's packed and ready to go NOW, gently tell her that it's a little late today, maybe tomorrow. Little white lies, vague time frames (they forget anyway!), something to assuage their anxiety and give them hope, even though you know it's a false hope. We use these fibs, little white lies, bend the truth to help calm them, not to hurt them. Real lies are told to CYA, hurt others or just spread untruths. This isn't the case with dementia. Often it's one way to calm them, until the next crisis arises in their minds! You can also just help her to live out of the suitcases, rather than putting everything back every day.

As annoying as this behavior is, it is rather benign. I would take that over those who become combative, aggressive, nasty, and those who refuse to do ANYTHING you try to get them to do, eat, bathe, toilet, meds, etc.! If she ever does start refusing to work with you, it might be worthwhile to hire someone to assist with tasks - often they will work with someone else, but not family.

Best of luck!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Disgustedtoo. I do have an aide once a week. Working on getting more
(0)
Report
my suggestion, and I don't know if it will help your situation although it did help with my grandmother with Dementia, is to give her a suitcase and let her pack then leave the packed open suitcase on the dresser in her room. If the sign is not helping I would get rid of it. I don't know if there is any way you can make the room look like hers from her previous home (it might help with disorientation). I also would limit the number of items in her room (maybe only give her a weeks worth of clothing at at time?)
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
i actually did try that, didn’t work LOL. She kept bringing the suitcase to the front door. ‘Sigh’. The downsizing helps though. Thanks
(1)
Report
You need to face something. Your mother has dementia and she will keep driving you nuts day after day and you are the fool for doing what you are doing. You cannot stop her. The only thing you can do is mark her name into everything important and REMOVE ALL OTHER ITEMS. This is typical behavior and the nursing staff has their hands full dealing with it. But if there is nothing to pack, then she can't cause so many problems. Do not arrange, pack, move, etc. It is NOT going to stop. If it is special, then you take it home with you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
tuffdecisions54 Sep 2020
OP has her mom living with her. Not in a facility.
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
You could try distracting her with photos of her childhood and family. I used to do this with my mother-in-law and it helped her forget about going home for awhile each time.
We'd also talk about her past, her family, childhood and young adult life. She enjoyed that.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
Destiny54. I found the other day a tote full of pictures I brought back from her home that I cleared out last year. She sat for hours just going through them. They do love talking about the past l, don’t they! .......Linda
(0)
Report
Time for a change-- when she is at breakfast-- take anything except a couple changes of clothes -- home with you... then integrate what you have in a small way -- minus the junk back in the room. If she asks where it all is-- say it was relocated, not by you, but the management. And tell the staff to keep mum. Go on the offensive ! And stop letting yourself be victimized by the dementia. Dementia never fights fair-- why should you. And a white lie is the norm. Eventually she will forget she even had a home... question? Have you sold her place yet ? Get to work-- clean it up--- dump stuff-- give it to the Goodwill-- get rid of it-- clean up the house and sell it! You are the Power of Attorney ! Be that POA !
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Lindajc2 Sep 2020
I have since downsized her room. You’re right, less to pack up. Her home (1200 miles away) was emptied and sold. That was a fun time...NOT. Having to make decisions of what to bring back to my home, what to give away and what to trash. So many pictures of people I didn’t know, or my husband. What are we to to with all these pictures?! She is the last of her family, only ones left is my husband and her other son. Other son took what he wanted. So sad to just trash them. Of course I brought back a totes bag full of them for sally. But going forward, since I took out of her room a lot of unneeded/unnecessary items, she still packs, it’s just not ALLLL over the room now. Thank you everyone for your input
(5)
Report
Lockett2166 said it right. I just lost my mother and I wish she was still her for me to care for. Please, know this time will pass. Take care.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Imho, you can not reason with someone whose brain is broken. It is a futile effort. Leave only the bare minimum within her boundaries. Prayers sent.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter