Follow
Share

Hello everyone
Came across the story of a lady with Alzheimer's in a Nursing home who had a medical emergency. The doctor and EMTs decided it was in her "best interest" not to go to the hospital. She did pass
Thoughts?

Thank you for posting this question. I looked at the article in People. It provides a lot of details about the case. Based on those details, I think the paramedics and the physician acted appropriately. Other folks could reasonably disagree.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Rosered6
Report

My dad was taken over and over to the hospital (not his decisions as he was not communicating much at all at that point) when they thought he would probably die at the hospital. This went on for over a year. He did not have a DNR as he was against having one. At one point the EMT refused to bring dad back to the nursing home until the hospital stopped the bleeding in his arm after a botched procedure.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JustAnon
Report

Maryland had something called a MOLST form. Mom's doctor made sure we had it filled out. We were told if EMS ever came to the house to make the MOLST form available.

I think it essentially a DNR form from the state of Maryland.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to brandee
Report

This is not a thing in the US -- unless the patient had an Advance Healthcare Directive, DNR or POLST already in place stating "Do not hospitalize" or "Comfort care only".

Where did you find this story? The info doesn't add up.

Personally I find it a little hard to believe that any American doctor or EMT would make that call when they are not that person's legal medical representative and they know the rules. Doctors take an oath to save lives -- and they are deeply worried about *liability*.

To answer your actual question: in the US only a person's legal representative (MPoA or guardian) can make that call, or via the patient's legal documents stating such instructions.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
Sandra2424 13 hours ago
Excellent response . I agree with you and am wondering if the story is accurate or true.
(1)
Report
See 3 more replies
I would say the resident had a DNR in place. People in NHs usually have DNRs. I do feel that a doctor can decide if a resident should be taken to a hospital. They are very aware when someone is transitioning and this may have been the case.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Being in a nursing home, they must have had a DNR and Advanced Directives on file stating no transport to the hospital. EMS and doctors cannot just pick and choose who lives or dies on a whim. If the patient is competent, they or their POA can also refuse transport. I am doubtful that the report of this incident is accurate. It sounds like a family complaint used to blame the dr and EMS for their relative's death. It reminds me of the "hospice killed my mother" posts that occasionally show up on this site. Let's use this story as another reminder to get our paperwork and instructions completed and up to date.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Sandra2424
Report

x
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Sandra2424
Report

I’m thinking about how frightening an ER can be for people *without* cognitive issues. Then imagine a frail elderly person suffering from dementia.

If it’s me, DNR and comfort care.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to SnoopyLove
Report
ElizabethAR37 2 hours ago
Yes, for sure!
(0)
Report
Do you want to be kept alive with an advanced disease that erodes your brain and takes more and more away from you on a daily basis? I don't. It was in my mother's best interest to be spared going back and forth to the ER over and over again and to have hospice keep her comfortable until God decided it was time to end her misery on earth.

My thoughts are there's always more to a news story than the "if it bleeds it leads" portions reported.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
Beedevil66 16 hours ago
That makes sense.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter