Follow
Share

Mom is now about at mid-stage dementia and declining. We got her a Life Alert system once she was diagnosed.


I stop in several times a week and usually find her pendant sitting in the kitchen. I have her put it on and she always replies, “I just forgot, I’ll keep it on from now on.” She always asks how to use it and I’ll tell her every time how to activate it if she falls or feels unsafe.


Is there a particular system that would be more appropriate for her?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Sounds like Mom should not be living alone and needs 24/7 supervision in assisted living .
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

If your mother has dementia, she should not be living alone. Period. Figure out what needs to happen now.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Your mom should not be living alone period. She needs 24 hour monitoring. If a fire happens, your mom could die in her house because she cannot use her correct judgement anymore. We were all in denial and that is why we are contributing to this forum.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

My parents always took theirs off even before dementia. Even though it was waterproof, they thought they couldn’t wear it in the shower either. I think some systems have a bracelet that they can wear as well. I didn’t find anything to replace it. That’s when the caregivers started to go more often and I installed WebCams.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Yes, there's a better system than the LifeAlert. It's called move her into assisted living where she's never alone. The other better system is called hire live-in caregivers so she can remain in her home if possible.

If your mother's dementia is at the point where she can't remember how to press the button on a LifeAlert pendant and call for help, she CANNOT live alone anymore.

I am still shocked when see posts like this. I shouldn't be having been an in-home caregiver for 25 years and now in the business of it. Yet, I still am.

Think of your mother in terms of a kindergarten age child. Would you leave a child living alone in a house as long as you stopped by several times a week? No, of course not.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

Thank you Burnt caregiver for the honest response. My sibling had POA & left my mom who had dementia living in her home for almost 2 years & wouldn’t listen to me. I called APS numerous times but they didn’t do anything until I told them if there was a fire she couldn’t get out on her own.

Some people are just in denial
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
BurntCaregiver May 23, 2025
@Jada

Unfortunately what you're saying is true. Many people are in denial about elderly family living on their own. I've called APS many times. Sure, you may anger the person you're calling on. You may get the wrath of family who don't want to place a LO. No one said doing the right thing was easy or fun. It's usually not either.
(4)
Report
A life alert device is not nearly enough support for your mother. She needs to be in a facility or have in-home care, probably 24/7.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
jules925 May 23, 2025
dissagree
(0)
Report
It’s called speed dial on a cell phone
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Jacquelinezr May 23, 2025
You're assuming she can still use speed dial. My mother no longer has the capability of using the phone, even speed dial.
(4)
Report
You can set up cameras in the home so you can keep an eye on her. I set up the SimpliSafe system in her house with cameras in every room so I can keep an eye on her when I'm not there. And if any door opens, I get an immediate ding on my phone. She won't keep any pendant (like Life Alert) on, so this was a good option for us.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Thanks for sharing your concerns. This is such a hard spot to be in.

When my parents were 90, they lived in their own home. My brother and I lived in different states. We hesitated getting Life Alert bc I did not think my parents would know how to use it. And like you, I assumed my parents would take it off.

We would call our parents often, visit for the holidays. Our parents insisted that they were "fine" and did not need help. We took their word for it.

They looked presentable, the house was in order.

But it wasn't until I saw them for an extended visit, after the family meals and usual smiling faces wore off, where I discovered they did in fact need help.

My mom was going to the beauty parlor once a week, so she looked clean. But she was not bathing. No one knew when she last bathed.

Once the family visits ended, she'd put on her sweats, sleep in them and stay in them for days. She was wearing dirty old slippers that I had never seen before. But that's because she kept them in her bedroom closet, and I had no reason to go in there.

Both my parents' toenails were a mess. No one thinks to look at toenails. Because mostly we don't see them. I went in to their bathroom for some clippers, and discovered their bathroom looked like a hoarding situation. The rest of the house was in perfect condition. But I didn't know this, because during previous visits, I had no reason to go upstairs into their bathroom.

I was ashamed that I had let my mom live this way, despite her assurance that she and my dad were "doing just fine."

We ended up moving our parents out of their house to a neighborhood near my brother. That was two years ago.

In those two years we started with an in-home caregiver, twice a week, to get their hygiene under control. We added cameras to every room.

Then we slowly added caregiver shifts, as both parents began to decline.

They did not like the caregivers at first. Insisted they didn't need the help. But they refused to move to an assisted living facility.

After about a year and a half, we added 24 hours of in-home caregivers.

We got to my parents just in time--if we had listened to them when they told us they were "doing just fine" who knows what condition they'd be in.

They have been living in their new home near my brother for two years and three months. A month ago I started them on hospice. Their decline had begun when we moved them, we just didn't "see" it.

So I am glad we took action when we did. We got them out of their living situation, despite assurances they were fine. It was not easy but it needed to be done and they have much better care than when they lived alone.

Hopefully you can glean something helpful from my experience. And I hope you can find what works best for you and your situation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

get in home cameras in every room but bath. They are extremely inexpensive and takes a load off your mind. My mom was accidentally hitting her life alert and EMS to the home way too many times. Now when they call - I check the cameras to see her not on the floor (she accidentally hit)..........
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Dementia only goes one way - downhill. It’s time to seriously investigate memory care facilities in your area and plans to move her to one. If you have POA for her, speak with her PCP re options for your mother. Until she moves to a care facility, cameras setup in her house might be helpful. The life alert system may work ok for those in the very beginning stage of dementia but not beyond.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Mom shouldn't be living alone. She will never remember it or if she does, she won't know what it's for or how to operate it.

Do not take her into your home and do not move into hers. A live-in caregiver is something you might want to consider, but that won't keep mom safe because the CG has to sleep sometimes. You'd need a team, probably three. Then relief caregivers. And you'd have to manage it.

The system you are looking for exists in a memory care facility. My husband is in one. He went there when I could no longer keep him safe at home. You may think that time is a long way away, but it isn't. Start looking at facilities now, and good luck in finding the right one for your mom.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

if she can’t figure out how to use the life alert she will not know what to do if there is a fire in her house.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I agree with everyone else that she's no longer safe alone. My mom failed to use hers when she wandered off and they couldn't find her unless she activated it. She did take a fall,while she wore it and was rescued after they broke her locked door. That was replaced with a digital and the code shared with first responders.
That was a good effort to get the life alert,I hope you don't have a long contract to deal with. They'll only stop the billing after you return the system. Mom was missing a little key fob and they charged $100,at least they closed the account,finally!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

A button won’t help her at this point. I bought fall alert button for my mom and when I came home from work, she was on the floor. I asked, “why didn’t you press the button?!” She replied, “what button?” ..more importantly, it was supposed to be activated when she fell! It didn’t go off..& after that I never left mom alone anymore. Hugs 🤗
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

The Apple watches will automatically call 911 if the user falls but someone still has to charge them every night and put them on every day.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

At this point, your loved one needs "people alert," human beings with her 24/7 to keep her safe.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This type of device is of no use to her if she doesn't know how to use it appropriately.

Can you place a couple cameras in her home so you can keep an eye on her?

I don't know much about home cameras, so a family member bought and gave us a Blink camera, which is from Amazon, and they helped me to set up the app on my phone. It's not a great system, I don't know if others are better, but it works for my needs. I can keep an eye on my immobile husband if I leave the house for a bit to run errands, or go over to a neighbor's house for a little break.
I just check in on him from my phone, and I can talk to him through the same camera, and I can hear him. He's not really conversational, he has dementia, he mostly moans and groans and yells help a lot.

My husband would not know how to use a wearable device to get help. He just needs 24 hour supervision. I shouldn't even leave him for an hour like I do, but I have no one to help with his care, and the camera makes me feel better that I can look in on him and see if there's any trouble. And, I just need to get away sometimes! Even for a little bit!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

When I was researching devices, the comment I frequently got was that it wasn't worth the money. The issues being: 1) the person didn't remember to put it on/have available to them 2) they didn't remember how to use it 3) they couldn't press the button.

If my Mom fell, she no longer had the strength to move her body to free her hand to even get to a phone.

A better solution, especially if she is spending time alone, is for her to have someone always immediately available.

Yes, I understand that this is a huge inconvenience. That is why senior day care, assisted living centers and memory care units are reasonable, yet costly alternatives to the issue.

P.S. I did get my Mom an Apple watch, which allowed me to abruptly stop whatever I was doing, and get to my Mom. One time, she was able to call out to us using the watch's SOS feature. The point being that one of us was contacted, which then everyone attempted to get hold of the designated contact (me)....who then immediately went to my Mom. However, the use of the Apple Watch required her to wear it.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter