Panurse25 Asked August 22, 2026
Has anybody else been forced to do a mandatory 24 hour learning block at a LTAC in order to bring a loved one home?
Follow
Share
My father is at a LTAC for pneumonia. He has for the past 10 years used a ventilator at night for sleep apnea. He also has a tracheostomy that he has had for 10 years. The LTAC is mandating that we do a 24 hour learning block in order to bring him home. Im not against extra training but to stay 24 hours seems excessive. I can see if this was all brand new but its not. Im also a RN with a master's degree and have been in multiple fields of nursing for over 20 years. Is this a new law? 10 years ago when my dad had serious illness requiring vent and trach they didn't make us do 24 hr at the LTAC.
7 Answers
Popular Questions
Related Questions
- My mother is an Alzheimer's patient and currently has a lock on the outside of her bedroom door Is this alright to do to keep her safe?
- How do independent living and assisted living communities screen out prospective residents who have committed felonies, if required to do so?
- Mother in a serious need for help.
- I've lived with my grandfather since 1991. He passed a few years ago and now my family is making an uncle live with me. Is this violating my rights?
Ask a Question
I might be tempted to consult an experienced attorney to intervene with some sort of release document you would sign to circumvent the training. At the very least I would want something in writing explaining what the benefits would be to your dad and what documentation they have that their trainer is more qualified than you.
I might call in the manufacturer of your product to see what communication they have had with the LTAC if any…
You might be able to get a certification from the manufacturer? Just brainstorming here. I’m sorry you are being asked to do this.
No one should be asked to not sleep for 24 hours for something so redundant. . Especially with what is now known about loss of sleep.
Here is a link to check out your LTAC from the Medicare website if you haven’t already checked them out.
https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/?guidedSearch=LongTermCare&providerType=LongTermCare
A Long-Term Acute Care (LTAC) facility can legally require competency training for family caregivers before a complex discharge, but a rigid 24-hour straight stay requirement is generally a matter of hospital policy rather than a fixed state statute. Under rules like the CARE Act, facilities must provide proper instruction for complex tasks, but accommodations can often be negotiated. [1, 2]
Understanding Discharge Rules
Safety Mandates: Facilities must ensure a patient can be cared for safely at home before releasing them, especially if high-tech equipment like ventilators or trachs are involved. [1, 2]
Policy vs. Law: While training is required, forcing a continuous 24-hour block rather than split sessions is usually an internal institutional risk-management policy. [1]
Discharge Rights: You have a right to participate in the discharge plan, and you can request flexibility if a straight 24-hour stay creates an extreme personal hardship. [1]
Steps to Take
Request a care conference with the LTAC social worker, case manager, and nursing director.
Ask if the 24 hours can be split into smaller, manageable shifts or daytime blocks.
Offer a "teach-back" demonstration to prove competence without doing a full 24-hour overnight stay. [1]
Would you like help finding your state's Department of Health patient advocacy contact or a local healthcare ombudsman to discuss this requirement?
Ask them to distinguish between a law and a facility policy. I can't find a Medicare regulation that says a family caregiver must spend 24 consecutive hours in an LTAC before a ventilator/trach patient can be discharged home. Medicare does require the LTAC to develop a safe discharge plan and evaluate whether the patient can be cared for safely in the proposed home environment.
Since you've been caring for your father's established trach and nighttime ventilator for 10 years—and you're an experienced RN—I think it's entirely reasonable to ask: “What specific competencies do you need me to demonstrate, and can I demonstrate them rather than repeating 24 hours of basic caregiver training?”
Ask them for the written policy requiring the 24-hour stay, who imposed the requirement, and whether there's a competency-based exemption or abbreviated training process for an experienced caregiver. I'd also ask whether anything about Dad's trach, ventilator settings, suctioning needs, oxygen requirements or emergency procedures has changed during this hospitalization. If something has changed, there may be legitimate new training you need despite your previous experience.
Don't frame it as refusing training. I'd say you're completely willing to demonstrate competency in trach care, suctioning, ventilator operation, alarms, emergency procedures, equipment changes and whatever else they require, but you want to know why a continuous 24-hour stay is medically necessary in this particular case.
If the discharge planner simply says, “It's the law,” I'd politely ask for the statute or regulation they're referring to. If it's facility policy, ask for a copy and request review by the case-management/discharge-planning director or patient advocate.
As a P.T., I have had to attend discharge meetings and instruction in transfers, mobility, exercises, etc. for my own family members, even though I worked at the hospital