Follow
Share

She goes out for a manicure once a month, gets her hair done bi-weekly, out to restaurants for breakfast once a week, trips out for ice cream and farm stands. All of this, with an 80-something- year-old male companion she has been with about 8 years. He drives her to all of these places. However, he has health issues and both are weak, hardly able to walk independently, but still they go. My brother and I are quite concerned they will either hurt themselves (fall, choke, auto accident) or they will cause auto accident and hurt someone else. The gentleman has 2 sons, but we are not sure to what extent they know what their father is doing. He visits my mom daily at her assisted-living facility. What, if any, is our responsibility as her children if something happens while they are out and about? not sure to what extent the sons know what their father is doing. He visits my mom daily at her assisted-living facility and signs her out when they go somewhere. We have agreed in the past that he could drive her within 1 mile of her assisted-living facility however over the month the visits outside of the facility have them driving all over the county on some occasions and this was prior to his failing health. What, if any, is our responsibility as her children if something happens while they are out and about. She would be quite angry if we contacted the sons and expressed our concerns. Do we have the ability to limit, if not refuse, to allow them to leave the assisted living facility. She has very limited short-term memory and confuses quite easily.

Find Care & Housing
Unless you know that your mum's friend is an unsafe driver (his age isn't enough to determine that) then I'm not sure why you don't want them going out and about.
Being nearer to home won't stop anything bad happening to your mum. In fact, being nearer to home won't stop an accident happening if the friend is an unsafe driver (in which case he shouldn't be driving at all).

If your mum's friend is perfectly capable of driving and doesn't have any cognitive decline himself, and your mum enjoys her days out, then there shouldn't be a problem.
We can't wrap our loved ones in cotton wool, that's preserving, not living.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to MiaMoor
Report
MiaMoor Oct 1, 2024
Also, not being able to walk unaided is not a reason for being an unsafe driver.
I have been considered disabled since my 20s, my stepdad can barely walk beyond a few metres, many disabled drivers cannot walk at all.
I'm not saying this gentleman is a safe driver - I don't know him - but nothing has been said to suggest that he's a bad driver.
(1)
Report
The only concern is his driving. Perhaps they can do something around AL?
Let her have some companion and freedom of doing so.
This reminds me of Jeanne Louise Calment, french woman who lived 122 years. I believe at age 117 she quit smoking as advised by doctor.
Or she was advised to quit smoking and eating huge amounts of chocolate? She ate half a pound a day or so.
So maybe she quit both.
I can understand smoking but chocolates, non.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Evamar
Report

Assisted living facilities are generally for people who need a little assistance and not for people with memory issues who require monitoring. Your mother's friend probably has no restrictions on his mobility - so he will go where he wants, when he wants. He is well within his bounds to do so and invite anybody along with him. This is a problem for you alone to manage.

Your options:
1 - Move mom from assisted living to skilled care or memory care that will not allow her to leave facility without POA approval.
2 - Put an air tag on mom - probably her purse or a life alert type of jewelry (necklace) so you know where she is at all times.
3 - Have another talk with this friend and explain your concerns. Give him options that let him know that longer drives/outings are out of the picture. Let him know consequences could result in her not being allowed out of facility with him.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Taarna
Report

If she is in assisted living I’m very surprised she really should be in a memory care facility wing of the assisted living
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Trixipie
Report
MiaMoor Oct 1, 2024
It doesn't sound as if she needs it, at this stage. It sounds as if she's coping with her condition surprisingly well.
(0)
Report
"both are weak, hardly able to walk independently"

Reason for my reply, he could kill someone. If he can hardly walk, then he is not capable of driving a car. He probably doesn't have the leg strength to stop a car if a car stops in front of him suddenly or a kid rides a bike right in front of him.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
AlvaDeer Sep 29, 2024
HOW did I miss that statement?
Yes, he should'nt be driving and she shouldn't be leaving without being accompanied by an able bodied assistant.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
I just told my daughter that if I live to be 100 and have dementia, and also have an 80 year old friend that wants to drive me to a hair and nail salon, and take me out for ice-cream, to please NOT put a stop to it.

I'd rather die enjoying myself than being cooped up in a building because someone is afraid that I might fall or be in a car wreck.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to PrimitiveGirl
Report
JoAnn29 Sep 26, 2024
Its not that they get in a car wreck, its that he may kill someone.
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
suegr49: Perhaps it is the gentleman's sons responsibility.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

Mom does seem to be doing well with her Dementias. I too would not want to limit her but I would also want to keep her safe. Can you talk to the man and remind him that you had asked that they go no further than a mile from the facility? If he cannot understand this, then maybe he has Dementia.

If you have POA, read it. Immediate means you now have control. No doctor needing to say Mom has Dementia. You can tell the AL he is no longer allowed to take her out. That would be sad though for both of them since they enjoy each others company. Gives them something to look forward to. Does the AL have a bus they take the residents on outtings? Maybe he can join her for a small fee. Your between a rock and a hard place here.

The other POA is where a doctor or doctors need to declare Mom incompetent.

My concern would be that he can just about walk. Does that mean he would have trouble putting on the brake to stop suddenly. I had immediate POA and I am sure if I was in your position, I would tell the AL he could no longer take Mom out because you fear for her safety. There comes a time when we are now the parent and parent is the child. Your Mom can no longer make informed decisions and you need to make them for her.

If you make the decision to not allow the man to take her out, that may be the time to call the sons and tell them why you have done this.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

You say that M “would be quite angry if we contacted the sons and expressed our concerns”. If they have an accident, you will certainly be in contact with the sons. If then, why not now? The liability issues are more for him and his sons than they are for you (because M is only a passenger). Perhaps just get in contact, but not to ‘gang up on them’ and automatically try and stop it.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

You say that M “would be quite angry if we contacted the sons and expressed our concerns”. If they have an accident, you will certainly be in contact with the sons. If then, why not now? The liability issues are more for him and his sons than they are for you (because M is only a passenger). Perhaps just get in contact, but not to ‘gang up on them’ and automatically try and stop it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

I'm impressed this guy goes by every day. At 100 years old I would like to be getting out. We are all going to die somewhere. According to the insurance industry she is much lower risk getting into a car with someone in their 80's than a teenager.

Let her enjoy her time left in this world.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to brandee
Report
suegr49 Sep 19, 2024
We agree to her enjoying time left, just concerned at this point with physical and mental limitations. Thanks for your reply.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
suegr49, welcome to the forum. Just curious, who told you there was a concern about your Mom's friend and his driving?


The way I see it, any one of us could fall, choke, or be in a car accident at any age. Teenagers tend to get into car accidents more so then older folks. And with regard to this gentleman having problems with walking, people of all ages who have problems with walking do drive. If this gentleman's children haven't stopped him from driving, then they feel he is ok to drive.


Let your Mom enjoy herself, my gosh she is 100 years old, and still on the go. Amazing and delightful. Otherwise if Mom is tethered to the Assisted Living, never to go out, she could pass on quicker as her brain isn't being challenged.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to freqflyer
Report
cover9339 Sep 19, 2024
Interesting you mention this, you may not have read about the 92 yr old woman who hit a mother and her daughter, (the daughter sadly died from her injuries). She got out of her SUV and appeared like nothing was wrong, and..

Just a few days ago an 80 yr old man drove around a blocked out road closed due to flash flood and died, (his car and he were found the next day). In this case, he may have have a suicide wish.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
As others have said, when can the POA be invoked? If you have a durable POA (DPOA), then it should be active immediately without cause, or however is stated in the document.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to SOS369
Report

I don't know what you mean by "what is our responsibility"? Do you mean legal liability? If so, there is ZERO responsibility. You are not this man's guardian or POA. You have no obligation to check up on him. Your mother wants to go to lunch, to appointments, wherever with him. Let her.

If you are asking about moral responsibility, again, there is none. This gentleman is still driving. So is my guy at 84 and he's excellent. Whether he is safe to drive or not isn't your business or your concern.

Will you at some point get a call that while they were out they were in an accident? That one of them fell? Perhaps. You are BOUND to get "the call" about "something" soon enough in any case.

I would not interfere on the face of what you have told us. I am certain other may. I would not.

I see below that you say you are POA. I have zero idea the level of dementia your mother suffers from. Only you know that. If you feel her dementia is so severe that she has no idea where she wants to go or why? Then, yes, you have some call to make here. However you tell us she has a beau, wants to get her hair done, get manicures, go to the farm stand, go for ice cream and go out to restaurants. To ME that isn't someone with a level of dementia in which she cannot make those decisions for herself.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

My brother and I are POA
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to suegr49
Report

If you are not your Mom's PoA, or you are and the PoA is not activated, then you have no power to do anything, really.

If you are your Mom's PoA then I would read the document to see what activates your authority. Usually it is 1 medical diagnosis of sufficient incapacity, Once this happens then you can dictate who she goes where with... but it doesn't mean she'll cooperate.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

What do you mean by “if something happens while they’re out”?
Are you her POA? Has she been diagnosed with any memory issues that would invoke POA? Without that, there’s really not a lot you can do other than explain your concerns and ask that she consider taking fewer trips with her friend. Unless she’s been declared incompetent, you are not legally responsible for her actions. And then, only if you are her POA and you act in an irresponsible manner.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to RLWG54
Report
suegr49 Sep 19, 2024
My brother and I are POA and she has vascular dementia and Alzheimer's
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter