Follow
Share

My brother tells me that he is going to file a lawsuit against Mom and I.


This is his complaint.


I was the POA for my Dad..he passed in September.
I am the POA for my Mom. She is the executor and sole inheritor.


I have been moving Moms money into various investment accounts. Mostly depositing checks from Insurance and pensions, getting into very safe investments.. I figure that even with low interest...the principal needs to be safe..there will be enough for Mom for the next 10 years.


Brother wants some of that money...he feels he should have been an inheritor. In fact, he thinks I probably influenced my Dad to change his will. (Not so...will was written in 1976).


I did everything to conclude the business of my Dad..on my mother's behalf.


Brother says..he will drain the account just paying for the legal fees...or I can just talk Mom into handing over $40,000 now.


I guess he doesn't have much money....so winning against him might result in a monetary aware for legal bills..I bet he cannot pay. How do I protect Moms finances without paying a ton to either a lawyer or brother?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

35 Answers

Most
Helpful Newest
First Oldest
First
1 2
Contact the police ASAP and also find an attorney ASAP who can set your brother straight on this attempted blackmail. He might be gambling that he can threaten or scare you into forking over $40K.

Research law firms to find an attorney who's handled probate litigation; you need to make sure to select someone who knows how to handle dissatisfied siblings who were excluded as heirs.

Was there any provision in your father's Will addressing someone who challenged the terms of the Will?

And if he does sue, make sure you have a good attorney who includes in the "prayer" (part of the answer to a complaint) your request that the court compensate you for emotional distress and costs, including but not limited to attorney fees. Your brother needs to be aware that he can be assessed with those fees.

He's wrong if he thinks he can "just drain" the account - he can also be assessed with filing a nuisance complaint penalties and end up bankrupting himself.

If he lives anywhere near you, you might also think about asking the police how to get a restraining order. Anyone this malicious might go beyond suing.

And BTW, I don't see any cause of action against your mother; she's the heir; that was your father's choice.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report
Bro is a pig. Check the law in your state to see if you can legally record him on the phone. If yes, start recording phone conversations and printing out texts and emails. Get him riled up and talkative, the more he says the better. Then take everything you have to the police and an attorney and ask how best to proceed. My hope is that any suit he brings forward would be dismissed based on his admission of malicious prosecution. If not I would rather pay lawyers than allow him one red cent, then I would sue him for court costs when he loses.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Does he come to your house?
Does he come to your mother's house?
Where or how exactly is he threatening you?

I think your brother is trying to frighten you into handing over money. It's a tactic. In my opinion, your brother will be hard pressed to find an attorney willing to take his "case". Nonetheless, I think a restraining order is your best course of action unless he finds some dope to file a claim.

That said, I agree with Cwillie. Even if you cannot record him because you live in a state requiring two-party consent, you can put him on speaker while having someone in the room with you to witness the conversation. It would not be a bad idea to video record you (speaking with your brother) and your witness (not saying a word and just listening) while your brother is on speaker.

Why do you feel that you need to answer your brother's threatening communications in the first place?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
I assume you are doing proper probate with an attorney and filing proper papers with probate court. He has to file a claim there, as part of probating Dad's estate. He won't, he can't afford an attorney.
Get an Order of Protection if he is threatening harm to you or mom.
I know you talked about putting your name on mom's accounts. Be aware that if you do that, as executor or POA, you will be is serious legal trouble.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
There is no probate involved. Everything was held in Joint Tenanacy with Rights of Survivorship. Nothing is in probate.

My Mom is the sole inheritor. There is no assets out side of what was held jointly

As for..hire an attorney. I cannot do that. I cannot justify $350 per hour. That is exactly my brother's threat. "Pay me or pay and attorney...either way..you lose".

My brother has nothing. Winning a judgement against him for money is worthless....he has nothing outside of his Social Security which is untouchable.

That is what makes his blackmail so effective. He can cost Mom thousands and he is collection proof himself.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Also, the family attorney is well aware of what Mom is doing to avoid probate court when she passes. He is the advisor on all that. At my request, Mom included him as joint POA. I have no fear that the setup of JT WROS with Mom is legal and will do the job if there is anything left when she passes. The accounts are set up so that Mom will have everything she needs for at least 10 years (depending on the interest rating we can get) before the last of the money would be gone.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
I'm just curious- what does ur moms will say regarding your brother. I know you have mentioned in other posts that you are putting things in your name in accordance with your mothers wishes to avoid probate when she passes - perhaps your brother is feeling ticked off and threatened by that - which may not be his to begin with - but may explain his actions. Regardless- don't give into a blackmailer- they are greedy and never satisfied- once they know they can scare you into handing over what they want it empowers them and their demands get bigger and more frequent. As you are working with an attorney be 1000% sure everything you're doing is on the level - cause even if you can stop your brother for now - you can be sure he'll be back with bigger threats when your mom passes.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
His blackmail can be effective only if you allow it to be. I see some points that could benefit from clarification.

If he has nothing but SS, how is he going to pay a retainer for an attorney? The kind of suit he's threatening isn't one which an attorney would handle w/o an upfront retainer as it's not a winnable suit.

People w/o legal background aren't able to easily navigate their way through litigation.

So throw his threats back at him. Don't let him intimidate you.

Not all attorneys charge $350/hour. Do some research and contact them and find one who doesn't. Some only charge about $200 to $250 an hour.

And most competent attorneys utilize paralegals to do the bulk of the work. That cuts the hourly fee significantly.

He may be judgment proof, but you're wrong in stating he can cost your mom several thousand dollars. He has to have money to do this, as I wrote. From what you write, he doesn't have the funds to support a lawsuit.

Call his bluff.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
KK - you haven't answered my question. Where and how exactly is he threatening you? Does he come to your house? Does he come to your mother's house? And why do you feel you need to answer his telephone calls if he's threatening you by phone? Let him leave threatening voicemails. Then, when he does, use them to get a restraining order.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Please. He is a bully who is intimidating you. Call his bluff. Let his calls go to voice mail.

You can't justify the cost of a lawyer? How can you justify NOT getting a lawyer, APS and law enforcement involved?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
GA isn't there a risk that an unscrupulous attorney with time on his hands and no better clients to serve might think it worth a shot?

I'm too disgusted to say what I think of this man's behaviour.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
CM - there is a risk for everything in life.

No lawsuit has been filed. And until one is, the best she's going to get is a restraining order.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
There is always an unscrupulous lawyer willing to take on an unscrupulous law suit. They take it without retainer and charge their client 50% or more of any money "won" - their hope being that some type of settlement will be reached to avoid going to court. The client also is responsible for all the costs and filing fees. In the end the client winds up with next to nothing and the lawyer gets a chunk of cash for sending a few threatening letters and blustering.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
My response in this circumstance is "Go ahead. And I'll sue you to pay our attorney fees." Personally I wouldn't even hire a lawyer. But then, I would also not put things in my name alone to avoid probate. That is begging for trouble when there are other family members.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Don't bow to the bully-ing. Actually, don't involve yourself at all. If he asks for something, ask him to send an email or letter with the details (this can be used later) Actually, if he doesn't have any money, how would he hire an attorney to file a lawsuit!! Even if he visited one, who would take the case? All threats, I wouldn't sucumb.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
CM, you're right - good point made. Such an unscrupulous attorney would more than likely also see that he/she can make a lot on feeding off the brother's hostility and desire for revenge, and also would more than likely charge a large retainer up front, to ensure that he/she the attorney gets his/her worth from a loser of a case. Read: exploitation.

That might be just what the brother needs.

There's also the possibility that the judge him/herself may impose penalties for filing a frivolous lawsuit and wasting the court's time. That would be a real slap in the face.


GeeWhiz also makes a good point in forcing him to document his threats.

Seems like we're all more or less "on the same page" in recognizing that Katie has a stronger position than she recognizes.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
I'm already cheerleading for that judge!

Katiekate, assuming he has seen a copy of the will, do your best to ignore his craziness, and certainly don't let him provoke *you* into adding fuel to the flames. This is demanding money with menaces, that does amount to blackmail: if you feel you need professional advice then see a policeman or a lawyer, according to preference.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I know of a family that did just that...contested their Aunt's will, and squandered everything intended for the deceased's son and grandson on lawyer's fees. The result was son and his young child inherited nothing; don't know how this family can live with that decision in good conscience. The beneficiaries obviously were the lawyers.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Do you have POA for medical and financial? If you do I really don't think he has a case as long as everything is legit. When my step dad died my half brothers wanted to know where their inheritance is???? Everything goes to the wife. Plus, he only had debt. I asked them if they wanted that :).
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Talk to a good elder law lawyer about an irrevocable trust for your mom, with you as trustee. That will avoid probate without hassle. Do NOT put assets in your name, it could mess up the possibility of getting Medicaid if it becomes necessary, will lead to possible gift tax liability, and would leave you open to your brother's accusations.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I have a similar situation with my brother. After dad died almost ten years ago, he thought he could take over mom's finances and help himself to the money. When he found out that I had been named POA several years earlier and he would have to go through me to get to the money, he had a tantrum, sent a nasty letter to mom, made several nasty phone calls to me and then stopped communicating with either of us. He will get half of the estate after mom is gone, but the funny thing is that after ten years, almost six of them in facility care, there won't be much, if anything to inherit. I still worry that he may try to sue me, claiming that I mishandled the funds and there should be money for him to inherit. If that happens, I plan to show the judge the checkbook where all the checks are written to the care facility or to doctors, insurance companies and her credit card. The credit card statements show purchases for depends, toothpaste and denture cleaners. It won't take high level math to figure out where the money went. My attorney told me that my brother will have a hard time finding an attorney to take his case, and judges don't look kindly on non-participating siblings.

The one red flag I see in Katie's situation is that her brother is a co-POA. As such, he is legally able to access accounts, although he is required to use the money for mom's benefit. Of course, if he does get some money and spends it, it would probably be impossible to recover those funds. If mom is still competent, I would strongly consider making you the sole POA.

Giving money to your brother now could create all kinds of problems. What if your mom needs facility care soon and her funds go faster than you expected? If Medicaid becomes necessary, any money given to your brother within the preceding five years will result in a penalty.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Can someone clarify that Mom is indeed competent mentally, and that all her money is going into accounts with Mom's name on them? Brother could have some reason for suspicion????? Mom inherited all Dad's money and now where is it going????? Maybe there is another side to this dispute to weigh in.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Also, Katie, can you answer whether your father's will has finished probate and whether your brother has seen a copy of the will? Is this just a case of "I should have inherited some money from my Dad when he died"? Also, what does your mother's will say about her assets if she dies tomorrow?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
If dad's will was a legally binding document I don't see there is anything he can actually do.It is Mom's money and she can do as she pleases with it. Brother has not rights in this. Remind him that if Mom needs Medicare in less than five years he would have to cough up the $40000.00 as it would be considered a gift. There is nothing legal he can do to "drain the account" you are the POA. If he steals anything for example getting hold of one of Mom's checks don't hesitate to call the police.Make sure Mom has a properly executed Will herself and of course she can choose to leave brother something but it is her choice. make sure every institution where Mom has money has a copy of the POA and tell them brother has no rights. You can even get a signed and notarized note from them all to this effect.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Put her estate into a trust.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Ok..sorry to be so long getting back here.

This is the story. Everything was in Moms name. She and Dad held everything I. JT WROS. There is no probate. Mom is the owner, and always was.

My brother is NOT co-POA. The family lawyer is my co-POA.

So...the family lawyer sent a tightly worded letter to brother. The upshot being, he oversees the financial move I am making on behalf of Mom, and agrees with how it is handled. if brother wishes to bring a legal action, he is advised to add the family lawyers name to the suit.

Brother left me a voice mail...backing off in a hurry. Now claiming he never made any accusations or threatened me with legal action. Sorry, he now claims I misunderstood his intent.

Yeah. I didn't misunderstand. But, he did. He lives far enough away so that I don't worry about sudden appearances. Mom is never alone. The home health aides have watched my brother in action...should he show up, they would not leave him alone with Mom nor allow him to dig thru files.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
All of Moms money are in a series of accounts in her name. Brokerage, CDs, bonds, etc.

Yes, brother was handed a copy of the will. In the first provision, Mom is sole inheritor should she survive him. brother and I are only named in the event Mom pre-decease him.

moms will provides an even split between us. The only exceptions being the family jewelry, which goes to me. As is has passed down through the women of the family only. But..Mom gave it all to me years ago, and I gave it all to my Daughter a couple of years ago.

So, it is clear that my brother just wants some of the money handed to him..now. He might 'get' that the money is going to be spent for Mom, and if she lives as long as her mother...that will be another 12 years. Long time to wait to inherit!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Finally, the only issue was with just the credit union. The bank and brokerage had no issue with WROS. This will prevent that from going into probate when Mom passes.

The credit union would not even consider a POD (pay on death) designation on the account. As there is enough money there to force this into probate...the plan is to move $14,000 into long term CDs in my name...one this year, one next year.....and transfer the rest out. Those CDs will be used over the course of the next couple years to pay Moms bills. The terms at the credit union is just too good to miss... Anywhere else pays poorly AND will charge a fee for withdrawal! Since we know that some funds will be used monthly to pay bills, etc...this is the ideal place for it to come from.

Detail records of the use of this money is already provided to the family attorney monthly.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Katie, thanks for the very helpful (and encouraging) response. I'm glad your attorney set your brother straight and he backed off.

Truly, it is good to read that an unsettling and frightening situation has been resolved by intervention of an attorney. Too often these kinds of situations don't get better, sometimes get worse, or the poster is uncomfortable acting, for whatever reason.

And, I'm also glad that your attorney is co-proxy under the POA; that adds quite a bit of clout that an individual might not have.

If your brother were ever sued by an attorney on your half and on the attorney's behalf as well, your brother would literally be hit by a legal tornado. I've worked on a few legal malpractice suits; attorneys really know how to hit the jugular with they go after another in their field.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
I would definitely file a complaint with police, but also sit tight until you get sued. Clearly he can't win and you may be able to sue him for your legals costs in the event you have to defend it in court. If he doesn't have much money he's not going to be able to afford the lawsuit and is probably just trying to scare you.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
1 2
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

Recent Questions


Popular Questions


Related Questions

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter