Follow
Share

He takes care of our kid (4F) full time before she starts going to school but I am resentful as I am the only breadwinner. He doesn't have any plans to make any money for us though he used to a few years ago. He wants to continue being his mom's full time caregiver. Is this normal?

Wasabi, since your child has autism, have you looked into your school district's special programs for this? Legally it is required to provide specialized preschool with an IEP for her starting at age 3. I believe they are also required to provide transportation as well. She should be enrolled there rather than hanging around aimlessly with her disabled grandmother.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to MG8522
Report

Wasabi, I’m going to reply here to your explanation that dad’s latest is that he will “shuttle” your child between activities. Why can’t mommy be shuttled off to adult day care instead? Do you see how it is, that he puts before not only you, but his child? He’s been given the gift of time with a preschooler that could be spent counting the swans in the lake or teaching her how to fish or fly a kite or catch fireflies. All of which are foundational enrichment. Now he’d rather swap what could be his fatherly memories for “activities” so he can run back to the car with mommy?

I would A priority a consultation with a divorce lawyer centering on you getting full custody of your daughter. It’s clear only you are putting her first.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to PeggySue2020
Report
Geaton777 29 min ago
OP has written that, "his mom...Can’t stand or walk or independently do anything. She needs help with everything including eating and potty. She lies in bed all day."
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I have concerns about people who choose to be unpaid caregivers with the hope that they will get an inheritance after the care recipient dies. (1) There is never a guarantee that there will be an inheritance. The care recipient can decide at any time to change their estate plan or the care recipient might end up having to go into a facility and use all their assets for long-term care. (2) The caregiver might be motivated to maximize the care recipient's assets rather than spend money on things the care recipient needs. (3) In some states, inheritances are treated differently than earned income (e.g., what one gets from a job): The person who gets the inheritance can treat the inheritance as separate property, not shareable with their spouse.
An additional thing that concerns me about unpaid caregivers is that if a caregiver is the agent for the care recipient's financial power of attorney or becomes a joint holder of a bank account ("for convenience"), the caregiver might be motivated to dip into the care recipient's funds.
There were additional issues between my then husband and me. If he and his dad had said there would be no payments for the caregiving, I would have severed our marriage sooner than I did.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Rosered6
Report

wasabi(love the name and LOVE wasabi)it sadly sounds now that I've read some of your responses that your husband is strictly caring for his mom for the almighty "inheritance." And with you having a prenup will you even get to see or use any of the inheritance if and when it ever comes?
This is a f'd up situation and it sounds like you and your autistic daughter are getting the short end of the stick here.
Your husband must really want his moms money bad that he's willing to wipe her a$$ and vagina to make sure she's good and clean so she doesn't get any UTI's and the like.
I know of NO man that would ever do that for their mom inheritance or not. I'm just saying.
I have a son and hell would have to freeze over before I would allow him to do that for me. I'm just saying.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report
MargaretMcKen 7 hours ago
You may think that you know no man who would do that for their mother. Men and women who love someone are willing to do very awkward things for them, and hell rarely freezes over because of it.
(0)
Report
See 4 more replies
This would be a big NOPE for me. Seems hubby is hiding his lack of motivation in some fake altruistic story about providing for mom and child. Wife is getting nothing, and wife is supposed to get first priority in a healthy marriage. Dear Abby used to ask the question “are you better off with or without _____” Seems to me you might be better off without a partner that’s in many ways left you behind, but that’s your choice to ponder. I wish you the best
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

Wasabi I'm copying your answer here so more people will see it.

"He said he wants to continue to take care of mom, will shuttle our kid back and forth to activities. and will be in charge of appointments etc.

He keeps telling me his mom is not doing well and holds it over my head. That his mom is family too and she doesn’t have a lot of time left. And he refuses to get paid by her formally as a caregiver because there is an inheritance involved. He has one sibling who also gets the inheritance but who doesn’t visit much.

You are right that a 4yo needs way more simulation. Planning for a part time preschool 5 days a week and then extending to full time."

I'm glad your little one will be going to preschool, my kids both loved preschool. The husband is going to be an ongoing problem until he is able to accept that he has to function as a husband and father first, then as an adult child of his mom's second. Way second.

Is his mom still living "independently"? He will end up ruining his health along with his marriage if he's going to stay stuck on this idea of doing everything for her instead of moving her somewhere appropriate for her stage of life. She needs more stimulation than being alone in a house too.

And worrying about inheritance is crazy, for anyone under any circumstances. Of course she should pay him if he's going to work for her. Really pay him, with an accountant to make sure money is deducted for social security and the whole nine yards. If and when she needs care that imaginary inheritance may be needed to pay her way.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Slartibartfast
Report
wasabi87 9 hours ago
his mom is not independent at all. Can’t stand or walk or independently do anything. She needs help with everything including eating and potty. She lies in bed all day. Not a great situation for her either. Looks like I really need to talk to a lawyer
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
"He takes care of our kid (4F) full time before she starts going to school" this is common, I was a stay at home mom until my kids went to middle school. You don't make money but it's still a job. You can tell it's a job because if you wanted someone else to do it you'd have to pay them. Ask your working mom friends, child care costs a fortune.

"He wants to continue being his mom's full time caregiver." This is a very different topic, not to be lumped in with being a stay at home dad to a young child. And whether it's "normal" or not it's not sustainable and it's not being a good husband.

Have you talked to your husband about what his plans are for when your daughter is in full day school? That would be a common time for the stay at home parent to re-enter the work force. And that would be the time for you to become resentful if he won't.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Slartibartfast
Report
PeggySue2020 13 hours ago
Most 4 year olds are in head start, private preschool or homeschooling. Unlike when I attended kindergarten, children typically come in able to read and do basic addition. Head start programs besides being free also come with free breakfast.

If he is living with mom, the child’s enrichment is thus a demented grandma who may herself be expecting enrichment. She
(0)
Report
See 4 more replies
My then husband left me to take care of his parents when he was 59 and our younger child started college. He was a "quiet quitter" of me and our children and our home and the outside world.
I eventually insisted that he be paid by his parents to be their caregiver. I was not successful in persuading him and his father to have the payments be by check. He (ex-H) told me that his dad said he wanted the payments to be under the table. I kept track of the arrangement; doing so turned out to be useful when I filed for divorce about 5 years later.
I would have the same expectations for a woman in a relationship. Unpaid labor for a parent or parents should not take priority over the marriage, children, and the home.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Rosered6
Report

I agree it doesn't sound normal but I wonder if there would be a different response if this person was female instead of male.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
BurntCaregiver 12 hours ago
Of course there would be a different response if it was a female in this situation instead of a male. Nearly all family elder-care situations get dumped on women. Same with childcare. Only if this situation was reversed and it was a woman in place of a man, she would also have to be responsible for the care of the four-year old and all or most of the domestic chores and management of both houses. No woman is getting off as easy as this guy who's in an elder caregiving situation.
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
I think Geaton gave you the best answer. Your husband is probably 'Quiet Quitting' your marriage and using the taking care of mom as the excuse to live away from you and his child. By staying married but living apart, your husband keeps you legally responsible for him while he does and contributes nothing to the maintainence of his child or the marital household. You are financially responsible for him even if his mother is paying him. How would you know if there's some kind of private pay arrangement if he says nothing and no one else does? If he racks up credit card debts, you're responsible. No doubt he's on your health insurance as well and you're responsible for that too.

Ask yourself this. If his mother (your MIL) is so bad off and has to have him with her 24/7 to meet her care needs, how can he also watch his 4 year old daughter? Your child is not in pre-school at her age? He could be doing online work during this time to earn money for his wife, child, and the marital household. I had two husbands and both of them would beg in the street rather than freeload off of me or their families.

What kind of a man with an ounce of respect for himself and his family is willing to live like this? You say he's 51 years old. So he started a family with you when he was in his late 40's. He doesn't get to stop earning now because he doesn't want to work anymore or because his mother needs caregiving. True, work can be hard to find at his age and he may not get work in his field. He may have to take a pay cut. Or work a job that he believes is beneath him. No job in the world is lower than a grown man freeloading off of his wife and mother and not providing for his child. If he wants his job to be caregiving for his mother, she has to start paying him. Then he needs to send that money over to you for support of the marital household and his child.

The not living together with you and his daughter is what raises the red flag here with me. That arrangement sure sounds like a man who does not want to be a married family man anymore. Maybe you would do well to have a free consultation with a divorce lawyer and just explain your situation.

Tell your husband now that if he wants to remain married to you, he gets a job and comes home. If his paying 'job' is taking care of his mother, he brings in a caregiver to stay with her (that she pays for) when he goes home at night to his wife and child. If she can't afford it, she goes into a memory care facility.

I truly hope things work out for you and your husband returns to you and his child being his top priority. If it doesn't, you deserve far better than how you're living now. Don't settle for this kind of life.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
PeggySue2020 14 hours ago
Excellent response, Burnt. Add to this, the op is almost certainly younger than the husband as she’s the mom of a 4 year old. He has some nerve at 51 to quasiretire to his mother’s instead of working to support his daughter.

As far as job prospects, online is mostly over. But as we’ve seen over and over here, there’s a high and steady demand for male caregivers. Mom can pay him. Or IHSS can pay him. Or he can sign up for any number of facilities and agencies to get paid. You’re absolutely right, though. This is his child. His getting paid to support her must be his number 1 priority.

Op, please look into head start preschool for your child.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
It's not typical but it's not abnormal (except for the living apart part). For many years while his kids were young my BIL stayed at home while his wife worked FT. She had an excellent job and enjoyed working. He was having trouble finding employment due to his skillset (which was in Quality Control, so a mfg-related job of which became more and more scarce as these jobs went to Mexico).

Maybe suggest his Mom *PAY* him for providing 24/7 care? If not, why not? Or, is he biding his time waiting for the inheritance of her house and assets? Does he have siblings?

In the end it is weird of him to live apart from his family and think this is totally ok and won't have repercussions at some point. It may be time for couples therapy. You need to decide what you're willing to tolerate. There's such a thing as "Quiet Quitting", where a spouse basically recedes from the marital relationship but stays in the home/relationship, not wanting to go through a divorce. Maybe that's what he's doing?

Since being on this forum almost daily since 2019 I've come across a few posts where one of the spouses is living with (or practically living with) the needy parent.

You may want to see the therapist first by yourself and figure out what you want.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
Hothouseflower 13 hours ago
Geaton, Unrelatd to the thread -- I never heard of that term "quiet quitting". It perfectly defines how my ex son-in-law structured a new life for himself over a five year period that enabled him to walk out on his wife and kids.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Of course this isn't normal, and you already know that. And your husband is living with his mom and not you and your daughter, or are all of you living with his mom in her house?
You do realize that if his mom has been diagnosed with Alzheimer's that it can go on for 20+ years right? Are you willing to be the only breadwinner for that long?
Your husband OBVIOUSLY has his priorities mixed up as it should be you, your marriage, and your daughter who come WAY before his mom, so perhaps it's time for a wake up call for hubby, by moving out with your daughter if you're all living together and filing separation papers through the courts.
If that doesn't wake him up and make him fly right I doubt anything will.
Bottom line here is that you and your daughter deserve SO much better. I hope you realize that.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report
wasabi87 9 hours ago
Thank you. My situation is extremely fucked up. Unfortunately my child is also autistic so I have to keep in mind her needs before I can take a drastic decision like separation.
(2)
Report
No it’s not normal, and perhaps it’s not even true. He’s 51 and has a 4 year old child who hasn’t started school? He lives with his M (not you?) and you are the breadwinner? Really?
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
wasabi87 9 hours ago
I’m glad you feel that way. I’m embarrassed to even mention this outside as I never expected to be in this situation.
(2)
Report
His mother can support him. Use the money from your job to pay for your household, yourself, and your daughter. Put any savings and investments from your income in your name only. Anything your husband needs or wants, his mother can pay for.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to MG8522
Report
wasabi87 9 hours ago
Unfortunately we have a prenup so the money I earn is technically our money and he is waiting for his inheritance
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
No. He should realize that he is responsible to his wife and daughter before his mom.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

I think the question should be: Is this normal for you?
How long have you been married? Was your husband always passive, a slacker, or was he a good and responsible contributor to the household?
A lot of men are "Momma's Boys" and he may really be struggling emotionally with his mom's needs and her physical/ mental decline.
I think it's admirable he wants to take care of his mom, as long as he's not using this as an excuse to avoid real responsibility.
What does his mother need? Does she need a full time caregiver? Does she need help with activities of daily living? You say his has been living with his mom for 2 years. Does she live with you? Do you live in her home? Is your husband an absent husband, living apart from you?

If your mother in law is eligible for Medicaid's Home and Community Based Services, it is possible your husband could be paid to be her caregiver.

I've asked a lot of questions because it is really up to you to determine whether you are comfortable with this arrangement. I had several long term relationships with men who were passive and non-responsible before I met my husband. I was 48 when I got married, because it took me that long to find a man I could count on to really be there for me; someone who could make a decision on his own, and could tell me "No". There's nothing wrong with your husband wanting to take care of his mother. If it is a problem for you, then you need to talk with him about it and decide whether your marriage can weather this phase. His mother could live another 10 to 20 years like this. Ask him what his level of commitment is to being by her side and what is his commitment to you and your daughter?
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report
JoAnn29 15 hours ago
My daughter got married at 40. She felt the men she had gone with she was more a mother than GF.
(0)
Report
No it’s not normal. You have every right to expect that your husband should prioritize you and your daughter.

Your mother in law can live many years like this. My father had dementia for ten years before he died from it.

He needs to be a husband and father first. If your MIL has savings, it should be used to pay for her care.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter