Follow
Share

So... I asked for a family conference with the Clinical Gerontologist at the Memory Clinic and my mom and I have an appointment this coming week. My dad is not attending per the request of the Gerontologist. I don't want to manipulate the situation, but what kinds of questions should I ask or stories should I relay that will show the true nature of things so the Gerontologist can be another voice of empathy, guidance, and wisdom to my mom?

A little bit of back-story: My dad was diagnosed with Alzheimers so we have been going to a Memory Clinic ran by a medical school. My dad tells everyone that the doctors and "everybody" are wrong and he doesn't have a memory issue. They currently live in an independent living facility that we were able to move them to last September. Our reasons were for safety and we were able to get my dad to say yes because the apartment had just been redone with new flooring, paint, etc. (he has always been an easy sell on the newest, best, top of the line). However, now, he hates it there and wants to move home. I do realize this is the dementia and always wanting to return to something that was "better" in our past. They do still own their home and it is right next door to mine. My dad really is no longer an independent individual. My mom is his primary care-taker and does everything for him that isn't hygiene ADLs which he can still manage on his own. The facility provides three meals per day, cleaning, activities, and all maintenance. My mom is starting to talk about moving home even though she knows it isn't a wise choice. I think she is tired of listening to him complain and of course she would rather be in her home. The responsibilities that she would be adding to herself (and my family) would be a lot. I don't want to take away my mom's autonomy. I have already resigned myself to the possibility of them moving home and the added responsibilities I will need to handle in caring for their needs. However, I am certain living at home will result in my mom having physical injuries due to my dad choosing to include her in dangerous maintenance projects because "I don't have alzheimer's and I know how to do these things." She will also experience significant mental and emotional drain due to the added responsibilities that will be back on her shoulders. I fear this will shorten her life by years.

I have written up some "clinical" type observations of my dad's state of mind. When I gave that to the movement specialist at our last neurology appointment, my mom made the comment, "Well I hope you aren't putting ideas in the doctor's head." She obviously is feeling manipulated by myself and my siblings. I want my mom to feel supported, not manipulated.
Has anyone else gone to a family conference like this? What types of discussion did you have? What did you share? What did you ask?

"I have already resigned myself to the possibility of them moving home and the added responsibilities I will need to handle in caring for their needs." The most important thing to say is to tell your parents that you will NOT accept any added responsibilities if they move home, so they will have to hire people to do the additional work for them.

And then tell the doctor all of they ways in which the burdens would fall on your mom, being specific, many of which are hazardous, because of your father's inability to care for himself and to use common sense. Tell him that this would be an unsafe situation, and that you and your family refuse to be part of it if they return home, so they will have to hire help (which, I'm guessing, your father would object to)?

Think of it this way: it's unfair to put your mother in this situation because you agree to your father's demands that you artificially prop up his claims of self-sufficiency. She is the one who will be there with your father 24/7 and most harmed by the return back to their home.

Also, describe your father's negativity. Is he angry? Aggressive? Depressed? There are medications the doctor can prescribe to help with these.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to MG8522
Report

Not for the meeting but it’s time to get honest with mom about the consequences of moving home, and not expecting you or others to kick in more than is reasonable. For the meeting, ask about medication to calm dad’s agitation, his rants aren’t something that’s healthy for anyone
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

I was hoping for advice from those who have been to a similar meeting with a similar situation. I was asking specifically for suggestions of questions and discussion topics for the meeting I have coming up. Bonus points if that advice includes doing this in a way that supports my mom rather than making her feel manipulated. She is highly intelligent and fully independent and doesn't deserve to be talked to or treated like a child. Like all of us, she finds herself in a place she didn't ask for, supporting someone she has loved for over 66 years who is no longer the partner she needs. Thank you for trying to help, but I am not in need of advice for how to set boundaries or how to control my parents.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Stahtah
Report
Daughterof1930 Mar 20, 2026
I’m sorry the replies didn’t hit what you were seeking. I’m sure no one wants you to control your parents. I certainly never wanted that with mine. Perhaps the doctor could be helpful by explaining anosognosia
(2)
Report
When you say it is a memory clinic, what do they do there? Is it a weekly appointment for testing or do they manage your dad's meds?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JustAnon
Report
Stahtah Mar 20, 2026
It is an Alzheimers research clinic. They represent themselves as a clinic that helps patients and families dealing with dementia diagnosis navigate the specific challenges of these diseases. We have seen two neurologist there. One for my dad's Alzheimers and one for his involuntary ticks (he has had these for his whole life). Both of these physicians are managing some of his medications, but his PCP also manages some medications.This upcoming appointment is with the gerontologist and my understanding is that it is to talk through what is best practices for his care and what the future is going to look like. I just don't want to go to another appointment that I walk away from feeling like I just wasted another couple hours of my life. That is why I was hoping someone else had attended an appointment like this so I could go in prepared with points of discussion and issues to address.
(0)
Report
If you do move them home right next door to you, that's a road to your mom actually losing her autonomy. Things will happen, such as you know she's tired because this week was a struggle because dad wouldn't _____, ______, and _____. She's exhausted, and you want to help so you do some of the things that independent autonomous elders usually do for themselves. Mom's always taken the car for inspection by herself, but you step in because in the moment you think it's the right thing to do. On the way home, you stop off to buy bananas for dad's cereal because last time there were no bananas, he became very angry; he's that way now because of dementia. And you don't want him getting mad at mom. She's too tired to eat well; she doesn't need more to worry about and looks like she's losing weight. Because the gas in mom's car is low, you stop at the gas station. Mom is grateful. Soon she's asking you to do more of these kinds of things. You do them. You don't mind propping her up because you don't want her to lose autonomy. Then she's so tired she falls, and you're doing everything by then to preserve how THEY want to live. You're now the only one with autonomy, and you never wanted things to come to this point.

Question really is, how do YOU want to live as your parents' health declines? Time for YOU to decide.

I've been family caregiver to my parents (now deceased), another relative, and my husband. Four times. I learned a bit late in the game that it COULD have boiled down to more of what I want, and less of what they want. Imagine that!

It's kind of you to want your mom to feel supported, but her feelings are owned by her. You're not responsible for how anyone feels. You can't make mom feel one way or another. If you try to do that, in itself that's manipulation. You do you based on what you know should happen - and let the chips fall where they may.

I wish you the best of luck as you navigate this unfamiliar territory!
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Stahtah Mar 21, 2026
Thank you. This is actually very helpful in regards to Mom's independence. Our goal has been to keep the house so when Dad moves to the next level of care, she can move home. But maybe that is also a bad idea. My mother and my MIL are probably the same level of independence but my mom relies on me so much more than my MIL relies on my husband. MIL lives fifteen/twenty minutes from us and my mom, even in the IL facility, is only six minutes away. I hadn't thought about the level of "assistance" they both receive from us being a result of proximity. I just assumed it was different personalities. I think this is something to ponder over before we get to the point of her moving home when he goes into AL care.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
I think to let the Gerontologist know what you observe is important, so that they can give professional suggestions on moving forward. Write up for yourself all that you've seen recently that gives you the impression he should not be back in their house. Especially let them know that your father does not recognize that he has memory issues. That's something which will most likely cause him to get into dangerous situations. It is also important to voice your concern for your mother, that she cannot and should not be doing all the caregiving plus cooking, shopping, and cleaning. It's too much. Where they are now provides her with time to spend caring for him and still have time for herself. It also, I assume, will allow your parents to advance to another level of care as his dementia progresses. It might be suggested that in home care is something to consider if they should move back home. You must let the Gerontologist know if you have limitations are on that and how to protect your own interests. With you right next door it will be too easy for your parents to depend on you. If that is not fine with you, let it be known.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to ArtistDaughter
Report

Your observations are key.
Finding out what your mom's "line in the sand" is.
Will she change his soiled briefs?
Will she shower him?
Is she able to help him stand up from a chair, toilet or the bed?
At what point can she no longer care for him? And what then?
Is there a Memory Care section of the facility where they are? If so is the plan to move him there?
At what point can he no longer be left alone? Is the facility where they are also Assisted Living?
Do you have POA? or is your mom POA for your dad?
If no one is POA there is a good possibility that you or a sibling may have to be Guardian. (I do not think your mom would be an appropriate Guardian)
I also suggest that their house be sold. Several reasons.
They can not make plans to return home if it is no longer their home.
The money can be used for his care, and your moms also if she needs that later.

To keep your dad busy and give your mom a break is there a way he can spend some time in the MC area so that he is safe and mom can get away for a bit. Or if there is an Adult Day Program that he can participate in that would be another option.

Is dad a Veteran? If so check with the local Veterans Assistance Commission to find out if he would qualify for any services. this may help mom later as she may qualify for Aid and Attendance. (may be means based depending on his level of "Service Connected Disability")

Also one more thing....Is dad still driving?
If so find out if he can be evaluated or if he should no longer be driving at all. The evaluations are pretty intense and he may not even be a good candidate since he does not understand that he has a memory problem.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

Specific to the meeting: I would start by clarifying goals. What is your goal, what is your mom's, what is the gerontologist's and/or facility's goal?

Then draft a list of questions and thoughts without any self-editing -- just sit down and write out everything from to-do list items to responsibility assumptions to just random "do you understand why I'm anxious?" questions that help you get your feelings out. I do these types of first drafts without taking my hands off the keyboard or even looking at the screen sometimes, and if there's time I'll come back to the document a few times to add more thoughts.

From this big ol' messy list, chop away at a copy of it to get it down to what questions you need addressed and section them out by who needs to answer them, how/when to ask them, etc. For instance, you may want to prepare a written statement that includes some of your observations, concerns, and questions to deliver to the gerontologist's office/team before the meeting. I did this and I know he read it right before we were brought back to meet him -- I think in this specialty, they're pretty accustomed to having multiple layers of communication like this.

You may also want a list of questions to prepare for your mom, your dad, spouse, siblings, etc. These may tend toward getting assumptions and boundaries spelled out and also convey your love and concern. Rather than "I hope you know I'm not going to ____" it can be, "I'm concerned about _______; can you let me know what your plan is about how that will happen after this move?"

It may also help for them to see some notes in print about what to expect from you, and these can be phrased as helpful rather than "don't expect me to ___!" For instance, if you have time to do 2 hrs research for them, pull together contacts for suggested professional movers, handyman, lawn care, how to use Uber, how to shift to having things delivered, etc. Let them know whether/how/when you can take them on errands or to appointments and provide alternatives so they start to understand the scope of this business of living under their current capacities and to what degree they can/cannot rely on others to take it on.

Early in the process with my in-laws, we told them we'd visit on Monday evenings to take them to dinner (or bring dinner) and out to the grocery store, and could bring them to appts that were scheduled on Monday afternoons. We explained how to have groceries delivered (MIL literally went to the store daily before her license was surrendered). Took a LOT of phone calls and complaining but we were not going to rearrange our lives to set up an exact replication of how they used to live.

Anyway, hope that is slightly helpful -- for me, writing stuff out and then pulling useful stuff out of the brain dump is most useful for planning. As for meetings, clarifying and coming to agreement on goals (and recognizing what can and cannot be addressed during limited time frames) is the best way to make sure it's useful.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to DaughterByLaw
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter