Follow
Share

I am at my mom’s and she has had such a good day, like her old normal self, that I am questioning my own sanity. It is hard to imagine this is the same woman who just a week ago couldn’t remember how my brother was related to her… I need to be reminded that I did the right thing by asking her doctor to take away her driving privileges! She is going to receive that letter within the next few days and man, is she going to be devastated. And right now I feel so bad because she seems like she could drive cross country and back with no issues. What the?

Don’t back pedal because Mom might be having some good days.
It’s temporary . She will decline.
She can’t be allowed to drive , she could snap back into confusion at any time including while behind the wheel.
You did the right thing.
Dementia is the disease that makes the caregiver feel crazy at times. It’s the disease with tentacles that squeezes the life out of the caregivers as well as the person with dementia.
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
TrishaAlvis Mar 19, 2026
So sad, but also so true. <3
(2)
Report
Enjoy the good day and be grateful for it. Don’t read more into it than it is, the cruelty of dementia continues despite the good day, and the good days will sadly lessen. Wishing you and mom peace
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

There will be good days. They will not be the norm. Don't question your right decision.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to JustAnon
Report

Aahh, just enjoy those moments of lucidity. Don't question.

Unless she had a temporary lack of judgement or confusion from a medical issue which has since been resolved. Do you know for certain that she has been properly diagnosed with a form of dementia?

I'm sure all of us feel that we are losing our sanity taking care of someone with dementia! I stopped in my tracks one night when I said "Good Night" to my husband, and he replied "Good Night" without thinking. He hasn't done that in 10 years. It's those small things that I treasure now.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

Stay firm, follow your instincts and do not be temped to back track!

I was the primary caregiver for my grandfather — apparently my parents felt caretaking responsibilities skipped a generation!

Although mentally my grandfather appeared sharp as a tack, I was concerned that his reaction time when driving would be too delayed if a child or animal ran across the road without warning.

Following my instincts, I told him I felt it was time for him to stop driving in his eighties especially since I took him everywhere but to Eating Together, an afternoon meal and socialization program that he drove to himself while I was at work that was less than ten minutes away from his home.

He refused to stop driving but did agree to make a deal with me that if the eye specialist I selected, who was the top eye doctor at a world-renown teaching hospital near us, said he needed to stop driving for safety reasons, he would.

When I took my grandfather in for an extensive eye exam, and even explained the concerns I had about him possibly not being able to react quickly enough to avoid an accident, the eye specialist not only said he was capable of driving, he admonished me for trying to take his license away.

When we walked out the clinic door, relishing in his success, he turned to me and said “See, I told you I can still drive! Now leave me alone.”

Fast forward just a few months later, and I received an emergency call at work from the director at the senior center telling me that the paramedics had just put him in an ambulance because he lost control in their parking lot and hit seven - seven! - parked cars before being stopped by a brick dumpster wall.

Apparently, he panicked while driving and instead of hitting the brake pedal, he kept hitting the gas. Although he was so severely injured, he ended up on a ventilator, he did somehow eventually recover and while he was hospitalized we arranged for the insurance company to dispose of his car.

Even though I continue to feel blessed that his stubbornness didn’t injure anyone else, how I wish I would have continued to listen to my gut and hadn’t dropped the issue no matter what that “expert” doctor’s opinion was, even if it meant reporting him to the police to make sure he was kept off the road.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to blueiris
Report
iameli Mar 19, 2026
I’m sorry your grandfather was injured. Something very similar happened to us years ago. We were parked next to one of those metal shopping cart corrals. When we came back to our car, there was quite a commotion where an elderly lady had hit the metal structure with her car and pushed it into our car. She swore that she’d punched the brake not the gas. I hope she decided to stop driving after that. What if it had been a child instead?
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
The doctor can't take away her license. He can ask his patient to not drive but he should notify DMV he feels she should no longer be driving. They send the letter to DMV asking for her to hand in her license. In my State, that took 3 months. My grandson was suffering from seizures from epilepsey. January his PCP informed DMV he should not be driving. It took till March to get the letter and he had till April to turn it in. So don't be surprised if it takes a while to get the letter if its from DMV.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

They have good days and bad days, as with most illnesses. You are doing the right thing.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Evonne1954
Report

Just for your own sanity - Have her reevaluated. It is possible she had a UTI that resolved itself and she IS actually back to her former self. If you didn’t have them check that at the doctors when she was “out of it” then you don’t know for sure. Going forward make sure you have this checked (try to get a sample to bring from home) because it’s amazing how this diagnosis is overlooked and what a huge impact it has cognitively on the elderly.

People are quick to jump to labels, especially with the information you’ve provided on this site. If you have doubts, let her be reevaluated professionally. It’s a big decision to restrict someone’s freedom and create these life changing events. It’s better to have someone impartial guide you; unless in your head you already know the answer but your heart just doesn’t want to accept it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Kat1313
Report

Don't question your sanity. Dementia is not linear in any way shape or form. There will probably always be good days and bad days for your mom. Its hard to understand all the ins and outs of dementia. What I can tell you is that in my life when my mom is having good days, my sister is on top of the world, almost giddy. When shes having bad days its the exact opposite and my sister takes her frustrations and fear that Mom will die out on me. So the best thing you can do is be realistic.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Valentine15
Report

There are a lot of ups and downs with alzheimers/dementia in fact we would generally see improvements with Mom every summer.

I think summer allowed her to get outside in the sunshine a lot and pick up sticks and pine cones.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to brandee
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter